Jefferson Theman retweeted
there's this mildly annoying type of person that doesn't understand the concept of set ups and payoffs in storytelling so they call the setup portions slow and boring and the payoffs "the part where it gets good"
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Piker's theory of change within the Democratic party is pretty flawed. With slim margins, they could tank legislation; they wouldn't pressure the party further "Left."
In a slim majority, both ends of the caucus gain leverage, but the incentives are asymmetric. Those who are closer to the center need greater protection than those who are further to the Left.
A surplus, on the other hand, means the party can lose votes in the middle, keeping those seats protected.
Further, note that Piker's "theory" of change exists ONLY *within* the Democratic party, not the country as a whole. With margins like these in the House, we could do big things if we get a Senate supermajority in 2028.
If you want true progress, you should celebrate wide swathes of wiggle room.
These people don't understand politics and they certainly don't seem to value actual change. It's all domination-games and psycho-emotional drama for them.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Looking up references of Dark skinned women foe one of my OCs and my goodness why are they all so beautiful?!
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Republicans have media like Fox News and Newsmax alongside Media companies like The Daily Wire. If you paid any attention to them over the last 10 years they all message on behalf of the Republican party. Trump does/says something, they all get their talking points from the top, and repeat that messaging to control the narrative all the way to the bottom. Trump doesn't need to message well, he can say something insane like he's going to wipe out an entire civilization, or he can invade Venezuelan and kidnap Maduro and the conservative media will sweep and cover for it.
Leftists have started to figure this out as well. It's why i can watch anything from Breaking Points, The Majority Report, Zeteo, The Humanist Report, TYT all the way down to Hasan's Twitch streams and hear the same messaging and talking points on whatever issue comes up (mostly just attacking Democrats like the recent Impeachment vote). They all have overlapping ideological ties (Democrats bad. Capitalism bad. Medicare for All. The West an it's allies are bad). Leftists politicians just like the Republicans don't need to focus on messaging, because the messaging will be done for them. How many times a day are elected Democrat asked about Israel as a purity test by leftists, meanwhile Darializa Avila Chevalier refuses to support aid to Ukraine even though overwhelmingly Democrats support Aid to Ukraine. But no one in the media attacks her for it.
Liberals are the only one's who do not have a cohesive strong media presence. Most conservatives think Democrats want to completely abolish the police and prisons. Meanwhile Leftists think and criticize Democrats for not wanting to do anything with the police or prisons. That's a direct result of Liberals getting attacked for years now by both conservative media, and Leftist media. The reality is most Democrats support prison and police reform but oppose abolishing or defunding. No one knows that because Liberal's don't have strong voices in media.
Replying to @VigilanteLib @HuntMiek
It is on the media for the Dems messages and talk? Wow ok that is some MAGA fake news crap. MLK warned us abouy centrist. Lose to a convicted felony authotarian by alienating everyone else. And here you are blaming everyone but establisment dems that madethis happen.FAKE NEws lol
Jefferson Theman retweeted
I'd say around 95% of the large, lib-left media people, including podcasters, are completely unable to discern between the different ideologies that exist on the left right now. In my opinion, not being able to differentiate between a progressive and a DSA/socialist type should be immediately disqualifying when it comes to challenging or interviewing these people.
"Progressives" or "wokies": people who are very "left" on social issues, concerned with many different identities (think "intersectional"), will likely want to fight on things related to abortion (woman's issue), racism (minority issues), medical/sexual health equality (LGBTQ etc... issues).
At their worst, these people can be incredibly annoying/toxic, but, generally speaking, I would say (personally) their beliefs are pretty easily incorporated into the Democratic party.
"DSA"/"Socialist"/"ML"/"Stalnist"/"Leftist" etc... types are very, very different. These people are trying to infiltrate and destroy the Democratic party from within. They are very coordinated, very cogent in their methods, and very, very easy to see when they are acting. They are campist, meaning they believe that every enemy of America should be supported. You can see this in the way Hasan supports China's takeover of Tibet, or his denial of the Uyghur genocide, or the reluctance of every single one of these figures to criticize anyone they perceive as being on "their team."
So far, they have been the ones leading the anti Schumer/Jeffries charge, they're the ones who tried to blame Massie's stunt vote on the Democrats and turn it into a loss for leadership.
If you're looking at one of these types and trying to figure out their policy positions, you can always ask "Will this weaken or strengthen America's position in the world?" and they will always choose the option that reduces American influence.
A funny way to see this play out is with their engagement with the Israel/Palestine issue: none of them will ever give you any viable solutions for the conflict. Instead, the only thing they want to see is America cut ties with Israel (and the Middle East, and Europe, and the rest of the world, for that matter) because this weakens America's position in the world. Same thing with their relentless attacks on American technology (constantly attacking data centers/AI while cheering on Chinese advancements in the same arenas) and anything else having to do with this country.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
I want everyone to be prepared for the next two years. There is a massively monetized online ecosystem, and not only far leftists, who profit off of doom and despair, and they are going to try to keep you as mad at Democrats as possible.
Because that's where the money is.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Looks like the leftists have found their unserious challenger for Speaker: Ayanna Pressley. Unfortunately for them, they've chosen someone who has never held a formal leadership position in the House. There's no way the House Dems elect someone without leadership experience to be the next Speaker.
Hakeem has a solid history of working his way up the leadership ranks. He was first elected as co-chair of the House Democratic Policy and Communications Committee (DPCC) in 2016. Then he was elected Democratic Caucus Chair in 2019, and Democratic Leader in 2022.
AOC said in her recent IG live stream that you need someone who knows what they're doing, can keep the caucus together, and sits in the middle of the party's ideology. That's Hakeem. In fact, his voting record is more progressive than someone right in the center, but he knows how to be neutral.
If this is the best challenger that leftists can come up with before the November 18-19th leadership elections in the House, Hakeem is going to win by a mile.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
what a privilege it is to be exhausted by an ambition of your own choosing
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Nah, I hate the version of socialism that is explained to me by the socialists themselves.
1. They can't explain the most basic, core elements of how their economic system would actually function in a real-world setting. Their vision gets incredibly convoluted and foggy when you introduce anything beyond the purest form of industrial workplace co-ownership, like contracting temporary specialized labor.
2. Socialists handwave the obvious knock-on effects of their system, like lack of outside investment or fiduciary responsibility brutalizing a nation's ability to dynamically allocate resources or develop innovative technologies with large up-front costs and no guarantees of future profits. Oftentimes they will just end up re-inventing capitalism, but with extra steps, to solve these problems.
3. More often than not, socialist "ideas" or "policies" are just vague, meaningless truisms that literally anybody would agree with (everyone should be able to afford healthcare, housing, groceries etc.) while also claiming socialism is the only conceivable method of achieving these ends, despite zero real-world cases to support this claim (and countless cases to the contrary).
4. Socialists will openly own the fact that any "counter-revolutionaries" who don't buy into their ideology cannot be allowed to exist within their society and will either be forcibly re-educated, thrown in a gulag, or killed. They know their system can't even theoretically function in anything beyond a totalitarian, single-party state where adherence to their ideology is compulsary.
Socialists have no real plans and no real solutions. Their ideology collapses under a feather's weight in scrutiny, and so they end up just avoiding any scrutiny at all, while forcefully encouraging their peers to do the same. Socialism/communism/leftism is nothing more than an idealistic aesthetic being sold to the politically illiterate, much like fascism. And, exactly like fascism, the ideology grants a false sense of moral superiority to those who buy into it, and anyone who falls short of total ideological alignment is viewed as a mortal enemy who must be destroyed at any cost to forward the mission.
Of course, for most Americans who are warm on "socialism", their only concept of socialism is "free healthcare, reduced wealth disparity, cheaper housing" -- ideas that have nothing to do with socialism and which liberals in our capitalist society already unanimously support. They don't recognize they are being taken for fools by actual socialists who want to fundamentally restructure their society in the shittiest ways imaginable.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Everyone mad about the 11 Dems not being there are being ridiculous. We NEVER had the votes because only ONE Republican voted with the Dems. Republicans would have just kept the vote open until they had the votes to defeat it. They can keep the vote open for as long as they want.
This is just an attempt to undermine Hakeem Jeffries as Speaker by saying he's a bad leader for not getting the 11 Dems there in time. Total nonsense.
We'll impeach Pete Hegseth the right way when the Dems take over in January.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Perhaps the worse thing Trump normalized is letting people who know nothing about a subject, never educate themselves about a subject, but sill feel free to express their opinions about said subject (loudly), and then expect to be taken seriously.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
So was Nancy Pelosi.
These positions are avatars for everyone’s grievances within the party. Republicans hated McConnell, now they hate Thune.
Normies wanting them replaced makes sense because they don’t understand the role.
People whose job is political analysis are embarrassing themselves by leaning into the populist slop because they want an audience.
Chuck Schumer is legitimately one of the least popular politicians in the country right next to Trump himself.
The American people voted for change and that's exactly what we should deliver. To keep the exact same leaders would be to spit in their faces.
Schumer has been Senate Majority Leader before, he is extremely experienced, but there is the practical reality of perception and what voters expect from us.
Jeffries is going to be the Speaker and I hope he represents us well, but Schumer already has a handful of Democratic Senators, like Elissa Slotkin and Adam Hamilton, questioning his viability.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
I don't know if you're intentionally strawmanning me, but given the way you've conducted yourself up until this point, you probably are. Believe it or not, democracy or representation has nothing to do with this; my critique is of the discourse.
I value substantive contributions and will gladly call some moron like Keith a slopulist whenever he engages in the noise pollution that individuals of your persuasion are responsible for. I don't love Chuck Schumer or Hakeem Jeffries and will gladly entertain serious discussions about their possible replacements, but until that happens, I will gladly continue to call out anyone who is engaging in the outrage farming that people like you participate in.
Because believe it or not, Mason, politics isn't a game, and me criticizing some dumbass for hurting the legitimacy of the only legitimate alternative to authoritarianism without outlining how they want to change it or offering up an alternative is not a contradiction. Rather, it speaks to my desire to preserve American democracy and fight for individuals' right to petition government for change.
The reason we are in the spot we're in is because idiots feel the need to engage in something they know nothing about. I'm not saying they shouldn't have the right, but I'm saying they should at least use their reasoning skills to generate a sound judgment instead of, like I said earlier, continuing to contribute to the persistent noise pollution.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
I have known Chuck Schumer for 16 years. I worked closely with him and his staff when I worked for Harry Reid. I have a lot of respect for him and have also had my differences over the years.
The job of leader happens mostly behind the scenes. The traits that make a good leader are not the same as what makes you good at social media, etc. Reid was famous for saying off-message stuff—lord knows how he would have fared in the age of social media.
When you’re in the majority, the job is about setting the agenda and passing bills that help people. When you’re in the minority, you’re at the mercy of the majority in terms of the agenda, so the job is mainly to get back in the majority.
By that measure, Schumer succeeded wildly on Tuesday.
He oversaw the biggest Democratic sweep in the Senate since Watergate, recruiting candidates who fit their states and putting them in position to win states many had written off long ago. He was an early believer in Mississippi, for example.
You can litigate this or that decision, and I certainly didn’t agree with them all—but when you step back and look at the big picture there’s simply no way to argue with this historic achievement.
To me, the question of whether Schumer deserves to be reelected as leader after the most dominant performance by Senate Democrats in more than half a century is straightforward, and the answer is clearly yes.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
been on this kick for a while, but i think the "money in politics" argument is way too obsessed with campaign spending
Elon buying Twitter clearly had way more impact on politics (both for and against his goals) than any PAC could ever hope for
There's a lot to focus on right now, but "The richest man to ever live just spent $200 million to support the Republican Senate candidate in Texas, and his man lost by double-digits in a statewide wipeout" is a completely insane sentence.
Put another way, the most expensive US Senate race before 2020 was $200 million. *One guy* spent that amount in Texas, and it doesn't seem to have made any difference. It might have hurt in a kind of Streisand effect way, in that the spending level was seen as obscene to people sympathetic to the argument that billionaires shouldn't "buy" elections.
The implications here seem pretty interesting! Especially re the limits of billionaire political power and/or the diminishing returns of money in politics.
Jefferson Theman retweeted
Republicans are going to have a terrible night, and the simple reason why is that Trump has put up perhaps the worst *performance* this term of any president in a century or more.
Remember that he entered with an actual mandate: the House and Senate, a popular vote victory and a swing-state sweep, and 6-3 Supreme Court. Democrats were afraid enough to vote for mild but real immigration restrictionist legislation in the Laken Riley Act. Everyone wondered how far the "Vibe Shift" would go.
Trump managed to turn that into essentially zero durable wins whatsoever. He personally *hates* the very idea of legislation, the notion that he would have to spend time going back and forth with Congress, learning details and making compromises. So he simply didn't do it! He didn't make a compelling case for abolishing the filibuster. He didn't try communicating clearly to the public in support of popular bills to get to 60 votes. He just decided not to do it at all.
So they passed an unpopular tax cut, some funding for ICE, and a sop to the crypto industry, and that was basically it. Least productive Congress in decades, due to the tastes of one man.
Trump adopted one of the worst macro policies we've ever had: high deficits, high tariffs, and attacks on central bank independence. We managed to pay higher interest rates while still having high trade deficits AND weakening the dollar. Just a total failure.
On immigration, perhaps THE signature issue, Trump essentially min-maxxed effectiveness and backlash. Instead of trying to leverage the political moment for new laws and a self-deportation agenda (that is, walling off the economy to remove the benefit of irregular presence in the US), he opted for a maximally aggressive approach. The administration spent attention, funds, legal manpower on stunts like deporting random people to Salvadoran prisons with essentially no due process. ICE and Border Patrol were encouraged to be aggressive and confrontational, which helped contribute to the shooting deaths of American protestors. It turns out, that's extremely unpopular!
What about the approach of going after employers? The obvious vector? Trump hated that idea! He repeatedly has said he doesn't want to target businesses (especially farms) that use large amounts of illegal labor. This is just an incomprehensible position. Instead of charging a few dozen businessmen and removing the incentive for millions of illegal workers to be here, you arrest people off the street one by one at the cost of thousands of dollars in manpower per each, while their crying wives and kids post TikToks about it.
Upshot on immigration: electoral strength turned into a crippling electoral weakness in exchange for deporting maybe 6% of the illegally present population.
The tariffs were a total shitshow. Embarrassing rollout, no underlying theory of action at all. No targeted focus on key industries. Our country tariffed products we can't grow. We tariffed *inputs* of our own valuable exports. The schemes and amounts changed constantly, sending the stock market reeling and presenting scenes of chaos to the world.
Trump's messaging throughout has been generationally bad. While facing nearly 2:1 unpopularity, he spends his days posting AI slop, saying he'll rename New Mexico or invade allies, among other bizarre remarks. He brags about a ballroom and a pool repainting while gas hits records. At no point has he ever attempted any kind of message discipline.
Then there are the deeply unpopular attacks on rule of law, his "game-recognize-game" pardons for all manner of scammers and criminals, the crypto schemes that he and his family engage in, the evilly conceived and embarrassingly executed legal attacks on Comey, Jerome Powell, and others. With his monthslong stand on NOT releasing the Epstein files, he became maybe the first president ever to stake out a 99-1 issue on the 1% side.
That's not even getting into Iran, DOGE, his candidate recruitment choices, or countless other things. Simply put: Trump has managed to royally screw up virtually every single facet of his presidency. It's been undeniable, voters have noticed, and there's really no escape from it. This is what the GOP base chose in early 2024, and this is the world they're living with now. Where they handed the reins of history to a fat, vain, washed-up old man and let him drive.







































