MacDad (@MacP1502) profile picture

School of Life

Jozi, South Africa
Joined October 2011
Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)Photo by MacDad (@MacP1502)
MacDad retweeted
Replying to @ME_Beaumont
I deeply regret voting ASA, i feel conned and used actually. 5 years of this????? You have taken my vote and are now using it so settle scores. nothing about service delivery
32
133
14
590
6,045
MacDad retweeted
I genuinely don't understand why ActionSA isn't accepting the deal the DA has put forward. Having read more about it, I actually think it's an exceptionally good offer, arguably far better than entering into a coalition with the ANC. Here's why. 🧵
36
56
5
188
11,298
The DA's 20 November offer is the exit from that trap. In Tshwane, ActionSA would govern the entire executive alone: mayor, deputy, speaker, every MMC, finance included. No ANC hand on the purse, no partner veto in the mayoral committee. A track record is built on decisions a party can claim as its own. Under the DA arrangement, every budget, every tender reform, every restored substation in Tshwane carries ActionSA's name and nobody else's. Blame would concentrate on Mashaba's party, but so would control, and control is what turns visibility into a record. The DA commits in writing to pass ActionSA's budgets and oppose motions of no confidence against it. Its MPAC chair becomes an independent audit of ActionSA's clean-governance claim, which is exactly the verification the brand needs. By 2029, ActionSA could enter the general election having run a metro on its own programme, with over two years of evidence that it governs differently from the ANC. By 2031, it would face Tshwane voters on a full term it owned outright. The ANC deal offers ActionSA the chain. The DA deal offers ActionSA the chance to prove something with it.
The coalition taking shape in Johannesburg with ActionSA in the mayor’s chair, the ANC controlling finance, propped up by the EFF, MKP, PA and RISE is a blame-diffusion trap set against Herman Mashaba. Political visibility is asymmetric in a metro. Voters know the mayor, not the MMC for finance. Responsibility for service delivery failure and fiscal rot will anchor on ActionSA’s brand, while the ANC, insulated behind the coalition’s collective face, expands patronage through the city’s purse. The implicit bargain is that Mashaba tolerates this, because any attempt to police the ANC invites a motion of no confidence by his own partners that put him in office. ActionSA’s electoral distinctiveness from the ANC rests on clean governance, the one asset this arrangement will destroy. Also, the coalition is anti-plurality and historically in South Africa, such coalitions have collapsed at four times the rate of plurality-included ones. And with six (or more) parties and donut-shaped ideology, the coalition carries every risk factor imaginable. Mashaba inherits the chain, the blame, and the countdown.
8
84
15
336
22,994
There is something genuinely clever about the DA’s “confidence-and-supply” offer to ActionSA. And I think its significance extends well beyond Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni. @geordinhl may have just introduced a new way of thinking about coalition politics in South Africa. First, understand the distinction. Instead of forcing two parties into one coalition, with shared executive positions, competing egos and constant horse-trading, the DA is proposing something fundamentally different. Each party governs independently, but guarantees the other the parliamentary support needed to govern. The practical arrangement: • ActionSA gets full executive control of Tshwane under Nasiphi Moya. • The DA governs Johannesburg under Helen Zille. • The DA governs Ekurhuleni under Khathutshelo Rasilingwane. Each party appoints its own executive team. No forced sharing of portfolios. No joint executive. No pretending that political differences have disappeared. Here is where the thinking becomes particularly clever. The parties agree to support one another’s mayors, protect their administrations against destabilising motions of no confidence and facilitate budgets. But they retain the freedom to criticise each other’s performance. In other words, cooperation without political surrender. Think about what this removes from the equation. The endless negotiations over who gets which portfolio, who gets to appoint whom, whose political personality dominates the room and who gets credit for delivery. It shifts the focus from dividing political power to actually exercising it. And perhaps the most important strategic move: The DA is giving ActionSA something significant in Tshwane, even though the DA received more votes there. In return, it is asking ActionSA to support the DA’s mandate in Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni. That is a substantial compromise, not a surrender of principle. But zoom out. This could be a test run for 2029. South Africa needs an alternative to ANC-led government. That alternative cannot simply be a collection of opposition parties held together by their common dislike of the ANC. It needs a workable governing model. The three Gauteng metros could become the proving ground. Imagine the possibilities if this model works. Parties could retain their identities, their political independence and their accountability to voters, while cooperating on the things that matter. Service delivery. Financial discipline. Infrastructure. Clean governance. You don’t have to agree on everything to agree that a city must work. And there is another clever political dimension. The DA has put a concrete proposal on the table, made a significant concession and taken the negotiations into the public domain. The question now shifts to ActionSA. Is the priority stable government and better service delivery, or is it executive positions, political personalities and who gets to sit in the mayoral office? That is a question voters deserve answered. Ultimately, this is what mature coalition politics should look like. You don’t have to love your political partners. You don’t even have to agree with them. But you do have to recognise the mandate of voters and put residents ahead of political egos. Perhaps the biggest opportunity here is not who wins three mayoralties. It is whether South Africa can finally learn how to govern through cooperation rather than perpetual political combat. @ME_Beaumont
76
83
10
346
20,394
The DA just published its own negotiating letter. That is not how deals work. That is how you make sure the other side cannot say no quietly. The Democratic Alliance has made a "full and final offer" to ActionSA for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Tshwane. The model is not a coalition. It is a confidence-and-supply arrangement. One party backs the other's mayor and speaker. The other party appoints its own government. No shared cabinet. No personality clashes. No joint governance. Just two parties agreeing not to kill each other's mayors. The terms are specific. Nasiphi Moya forms government in Tshwane. Helen Zille forms government in Johannesburg. Khathutshelo Rasilingwane forms government in Ekurhuleni. ActionSA keeps the city it already runs. The DA keeps the two it won. Everyone gets their own house. Nobody has to share a kitchen. Here is why they went public. The letter leaked. "Presumably from its recipients," the DA says. The phrasing is polite. The implication is not. If ActionSA leaks your offer, you publish it. Now the public knows what was on the table. Now saying no has a cost. This is not a negotiation. It is a trap dressed as generosity. The DA says it tried "every reasonable avenue." It says voters rejected "chaotic coalitions." It says residents "deserve to know exactly what the DA is prepared to support." What it does not say: what happens if ActionSA says no. Because we all know what happens. The ANC-led bloc assembles. Mashaba takes Johannesburg. The DA goes into opposition in cities it won. The DA won the most votes in all three metros. It is offering a deal that gives ActionSA exactly what it wants in Tshwane and asks for nothing in return except a vote. If ActionSA rejects this, it is not rejecting the DA. It is rejecting the voters who put the DA first. And the DA just made sure everyone is watching to see if it does.
📝 DA makes final offer to ActionSA for stable governments in Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni and Tshwane: da.org.za/2026/11/da-makes-f…
65
38
7
257
38,126
Dear @helenzille You went into Johannesburg, took on a difficult political battle and came out with the biggest share of the vote. That is no small achievement. Perhaps the most frustrating part is that winning the most votes doesn't necessarily mean getting the opportunity to govern. Johannesburg voters have spoken, but coalition politics may produce a completely different outcome from what many voters expected. Whatever happens next, I hope you understand that your campaign has made an impact. Now the real test is whether those who eventually take control can deliver the services that Johannesburg desperately needs. The people of Johannesburg deserve a government that works, not another round of political musical chairs.
32
93
6
557
15,676
MacDad retweeted
1. My final thread on the JHB election: I am disappointed that Helen did not win an absolute majority. She was the best candidate by far among those that stood. She has experience of turning a city, and she defined the election campaign from day 1. Everyone else responded to her.
545
285
261
1,697
227,897
Does South Africa’s electoral system protect voters from vote abuse by elected politicians? Why are politicians free to enter into coalitions with each other without voter input? If I vote ActionSA against the ANC, why must ActionSA enter into coalition with the same ANC I voted against without my consent or input?
39
53
4
228
4,146
Mashaba, Zuma and Malema: a marriage made in hypocrisy Back in 2024, Herman Mashaba explained why he got into politics: “I promised my friends and family,” he said, “that if South Africans re-elected Jacob Zuma as president, I would become a member of the opposition to turn around the country’s decline.” So it odd to see ASA advertise this week, “A first multi-lateral engagement with ActionSA, ANC, EFF and MK with a focus on how stability and services can be achieved for all.” To see ASA next to the ANC - an organisation Mashaba has described as the devil itself - is one thing. Mashaba’s hypocrisy on this front is now is so well documented as to be taken as read. But quite another level of duplicity to see MK and the EFF in the room. MK is of course former President Jacob Zuma’s personal revenge project. And former ANCYL leader Julius Malema’s EFF represents an earlier iteration of revenge. Mashaba has said of the three, “The ANC, EFF and the MK – those are the parties, for us as ActionSA, we will never work with.” His reasoning being, “It can't be the EFF. It can't be Zuma's MK's. These are all the brainchild of the ANC, all corrupt.” And yet here we are. Hypocrisy doesn’t really affect Mashaba, he seems to bathe in the stuff. But he did say, repeatedly on the campaign trail, that ASA had three non-negotiables, one of which was a “zero tolerance” attitude to corruption. And what do we have outside of the word of a party? It is hard to argue that Zuma has a “zero-tolerance” attitude to corruption. Indeed, the man himself is about to face a long-delayed trial on his own alleged role in corrupting the entire state. But don’t take my word for it. Mashaba said in 2017, “The past eight years of ANC rule under Jacob Zuma have, simply put, been characterised by fraud, corruption and a depravity of governance.” In 2023 he said Zuma “oversaw the biggest destruction of state entities during his presidency” “With Jacob Zuma,” he said in 2019, “we know he steals people's money and he does not hide it.” As a result, when Zuma was convicted in 2021, Mashaba said, “Finally, Zuma will find himself where he belongs - behind bars.” Turns out, that is not where Zuma belongs, he belongs in the metros, overseeing his rotating circle of deployees, managing public money. Not just Zuma, but his family, whom he was quick to point out in 2022 was no less compromised: “He is found to have abused his office for the benefit of himself, his son and the Guptas, and that Mr Zuma and Duduzane entered into contracts with state organs in an irregular manner.” There are many other such quotes from Mashaba. His public career was built on a monument of scathing criticism about Zuma. But the worm turns. “The ANC, EFF, MK out of the question,” Mashaba said in 2024. Now we face the bizarre prospect of Mashaba himself, after going into politics itself no less, to rid SA of the curse of the ANC and its wild progeny, happily and proudly in the process of facilitating their return. Mashaba has become the very thing he started in politics to eradicate: a willing facilitator for the corrupt or, as he put it, “constitutional delinquents”, “who have looted our country with impunity” and who are “characterised by fraud, corruption and a depravity of governance.” Today, under the banner of a “zero-tolerance” attitude to corruption, he is working to carefully manage their return, to give them access to public money, tenders and patronage networks. You have to give to Mashaba, those moderate forces in SA, even in the ANC itself, from the GNU to KZN, have compromised so much to keep MK’s hands out of the till. And MK and the EFF have done so much to try and get their hands on it. Turns out, all they needed was Mashaba. He is set to achieve everything Zuma and Malema ever wanted: access to state resources and a return to the glorious decade following 2009. Truly we live in wonderland. But don’t ever think the protagonist is Ramaphosa, Zuma or Malema. Mashaba is Alice:
11
54
4
114
13,178
MacDad retweeted
This will be my last take on ActionSA before I sound as obsessed as Herman himself. My intention is purely to open voters eyes. The truth will always prevail. "Know your ASA": X is full of "the DA enabled the ANC". The difference stays. The DA said they will do anything to keep the EFF & MK out, and that’s how it turned out. They did exactly what they said they would do. Locally Herman repeatedly said they will never go into coalition with the ANC. They broke that promise already a while ago. It’s still like that on their website. Here they plan to enable ANC, EFF & MK in one go for mayor positions. ASA had the chance to join the GNU nationally and refused. They said it was so they could be the real, constructive opposition. Two years later an independent tracker of the GNU’s 120 policy commitments shows just 4 fully implemented, 64 still in progress, and 52 not even started. None were classified as broken. Only 4! That's not opposition. Their own commitment is as bad as the ANC. That’s the score after they chose the opposition benches. If staying out was meant to force better delivery, the results don’t show it. Yet locally they flip-flop on the “never with the ANC” promise and negotiate mayor positions that effectively enable the same parties they claimed to oppose nationally. You know the biggest corruption is at local government. Not national. It’s completely different governance tactics and they don’t even coexist with one another. Last point, go see how many times Julius insulted Herman. Multiple times he has said Herman is their mayor. Yet Herman has a problem with Helen? Not a word towards Julius? Herman likes feeling validated by the EFF. He likes being a puppet. Herman the EFF mayor. A puppet mayor is what you will get. In all metros while the corruption goes on blind. Citizens carry on to suffer while people clap hands for Instagram filter photos of grass cutting. It’s sad. We all voted for change. Politicians wanted us to vote for them for power. Their primary objective and the citizen objectives are not aligned. An honest MMC can bring more change than a mayor by simply having integrity. Yet the fight is over being mayor. The one that everyone sees for credit. Like dear Moya being glorified and ASA will be the cause of her tarnished name... It already started with failing infrastructure. Herman used you. He is busy abusing democracy for his personal gains. FACT!
60
188
20
564
26,043
In my assessment, South Africa’s towns, infrastructure, and economic foundations were established by white South Africans. Since 1994, the black government has not developed a single town of comparable scale. White South Africans continue to play a central role in sustaining the country through key sectors including banking, insurance and pharmaceutical industries, retail, mining, media,and agriculture. And with the leadership and politicians we have today, I have no doubt that if whites left, this country would fall apart and become just like the other failed states in Africa.
73
13
4
89
6,912
Sounds like Joburg is doomed to be governed by a multiparty coalition that made up of ANC (20%) ASA (16%) EFF(6.5%) MKP (5.5%) IFP(2.5%) PA (2%). DA (35%) will go into opposition. Now how will the ANC coalition pay the R10b poison pill @DadaMorero intended leaving for the DA?
117
108
16
658
46,038
I often see this “black people unite” BS. 7% of the population is white and 82% is black. The fact is that back people did unite at the ballot box and the message is a clear - ANC, MK and EFF were given a hiding, ASA is a 5% party and more black people voted for the DA than there are white people in the country. These “black people unite” morons are the minority black racists that were rejected at the ballot box when black and white South Africans united for a better SA.
Nope..if anything, Herman will be president of South Africa in 2029. Watch. Black people are uniting. And it's beautiful to witness
10
31
2
133
3,762
This is very true.😪 "Speaking to 702's John Perlman, Prof Van den Heever warned that coalitions built around political transactions rather than a shared commitment to governing could result in fragmented service delivery and widespread corruption. If they are purely transactional... effectively you hand portions of the city over to party political control rather than an overall governing approach. And it potentially fragments delivery and potentially results in lots and lots of corruption." Van den Heever questioned whether the parties involved would be united by a genuine commitment to improving Johannesburg or by opportunities to access municipal resources."
13
36
1
96
2,248
THE DA MIGHT ACTUALLY BENEFIT FROM STAYING IN OPPOSITION IN JOHANNESBURG. I honestly think this could make the party even stronger heading into 2029 and reinforce its position in the Western Cape. Why? Because I don't believe an ANC–ActionSA coalition will change Johannesburg's fortunes. If the city continues struggling with service delivery, governance and infrastructure, the parties in govt will have to answer for it. Sometimes being in opposition means allowing those in power to carry the responsibility for their decisions. The 2029 political consequences could be very interesting.
121
75
14
594
24,070
We’re about to see the scavengers in South African politics form a chaotic, frenzied pack, so they can pick the carcass clean. Give them no quarter. They’ve taken enough. Do whatever you can to insulate yourself from the state.
136
270
16
1,790
46,391
They do not say, let us build our own Tesla. They say, you built Tesla, so you owe us a share. They do not say, let us build our own Starlink. They say, give us 30 percent of Starlink because we are black. That is not empowerment. That is extortion with a race card. Real empowerment is building. Entitlement is waiting to loot what someone else built and calling it redress. Elon owes nothing because of his skin. No one owes anyone because of their skin. You owe a country only what you choose to give, not what a corrupt politician demands because of your race. Until South Africa kills this entitlement mentality, it will never build. It will only beg, blame, and loot.
438
1,362
73
6,091
89,103
Imagine spending 32 years in charge of a hotel, allowing the building to deteriorate, the plumbing to collapse, the electricity to fail and the guests to suffer. Eventually, the owners remove you and give someone else a chance to run the place. Then, instead of allowing the new management to fix things, someone suggests bringing the old management back to run the hotel again. 😭 That's how ridiculous it would be for Herman Mashaba and other political parties to hand Gauteng's biggest metros back to the ANC without serious guarantees and accountability. You don't give the keys back to the management that presided over the decline and expect a miracle. Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni are not political retirement homes. They are cities where millions of people live, work and raise families. At some point, politicians must stop treating municipalities as political trophies and start treating them as responsibilities.
59
217
10
789
15,246
Two things pivoted China. Deng led the change. He was under pressure to feed about a billion people and China was dirt poor. He abolished collective decision-making. He said it drives the culture of impunity. He also banned the long-held culture of rejecting lessons from the “barbarians”, which he called their former oppressors. That’s when he said it doesn’t matter the colour of the cat, provided it catches the mice. This was preceded by his trip abroad where he met the sandwich for the first time. To him, it wasn’t food to assuage his hunger, but an idea from which China could be re-launched. Some have said China is the product of the sandwich. But our guys here, who pray to God Xi, have refused to learn these crucial lessons. Everything from Afrikaners or whites must be rejected without a thought. Even the inherited infrastructure was rejected through permitted dilapidation. That’s why we are where we are today.
4
8
26
1,084
MacDad retweeted
If you want to understand the state of our country, talk to the people working in public hospitals. The reality is heartbreaking. You will hate this government.
23
408
7
1,173
13,763