Seá Noor retweeted
This story is more sinister than just an anonymous troll account being exposed. And it should be treated very seriously.
Habibi UK smeared Jeremy Corbyn in 317 posts from behind a fake name. But it gets worse.
The man behind it, as just revealed by @BylineTimes, is Ben Tait, who was sole director and controlling owner of the company that spent £134,457 at the 2019 election, including on ads attacking Corbyn and Labour.
No donor was declared. £6,880 of it was paid to Tait himself.
So the "anonymous researcher" was the paid director of an anti-Corbyn campaign. He ran the adverts under one name and the smears under another.
That campaign was Mainstream. Its founder and chairman is Lord Austin, the UK's trade envoy to Israel.
Austin shared Habibi's posts at least 34 times. Habibi shared Austin's 79 times. A peer was promoting his own campaign's director to the public as if he were a stranger.
It gets worse in Leicester.
In September 2022, Hindu and Muslim men clashed on the streets of Leicester for weeks. Two months later the Henry Jackson Society published a report on it that played down the part Hindutva activists had played. That report cited the anonymous Habibi account in nine endnotes.
In May 2023 Michael Gove ordered an independent government review of the violence. He put Lord Austin in charge.
The Muslim Council of Britain protested. Leicester's Federation of Muslim Organisations told the Prime Minister the review would have no credibility. More than 100 Muslim groups and individuals in the city refused to take part.
They did not know the half of it. The man chairing the review had spent years sharing an anonymous account that attacked Muslim politicians by name. That account was a source for the main report on the same violence. And the man running it was the director of Austin's own campaign company.
This is the account that attacked 363 people. It called Stephen Kapos, a Holocaust survivor who marched for Gaza, a "stain". It called people opposing Israel's genocide "hate marchers".
This isn’t just an anonymous hater on the internet. He has secretly participated in so-called “independent reviews” and has been part of a network that has harassed, doxed and smeared hundreds of individuals.
Ben Tait is now a name that can be directly attributed as the figure behind these attacks. The recipients finally have the ability to seek justice against him, as a named individual.
Seá Noor retweeted
Yes, this is a major part of this story.
This broader network including habibi, GnasherJew and Labour Against Antisemitism frequently target left-wing Jews like Justin Schlosberg, Andrew Feinstein, Stephen Kapos, Michael Rosen etc. Quite often, when the true identity of these agitator accounts are revealed, they turn out to be run by non-Jews.
But this story isn't just some snowflakey reaction to robust online discourse. There are massive real-world implications about how this network operates.
First, many of the accounts in this network are anonymous. They say defamatory things about people who cannot defend their reputation - you can't sue anonymous amounts or put social pressure on named individuals to retract defamatory statements.
Second, these accounts directly feed into alarmist stories in the right-wing press: the type of story that calls Misam Harriman or Linkeker racist. These are absurdities. It is genuinely absurd that they are being accused of anti-Jew hate. Madness. Yet these accounts provide grist to mill for the press to go after public figures who criticise Israel or challenge the status quo.
These stories are important. They send the message to other celebrities or politicians that speaking out, even mildly, about Israel, can see your words taken out of context, driving media coverage, and then driving you out of your job.
They also create a sense of ambient, unrelenting crisis; that there is an epidemic of hate seeping into every corner of our society; that it is so pervasive that even the nice guy from the footy has been infected.
Most often this becomes coded and couched in Islamophobic terms - just look at how often habibi goes after pro-Gaza Muslims. The right-wing press is adept at using this to feed into broader "clash of civilisation/anti-immigration" rhetoric. This empowers and emboldens the far-right, but also builds elite consent for attacks on civil liberties and protest.
Third, the "evidence" these accounts produce feed into formal processes. Labour Party files show that there are loads of complaints submitted to the Labour Party with evidence from Habibi and GnasherJew. Some emails show GnasherJew advising people on complaints. Habibi, using a Gmail address, had complained directly to the Party in certain cases.
Mish Rahman has confirmed that candidates were blocked from standing for the Labour Party based on dossiers with Habibi evidence - the Starmerite bureaucracy, which routinely blocked left-wingers for nonsense, were provided with the ammo they needed to transform the Party by habibi and other agitators.
This is genuinely mad: anonymous agitator accounts, who code most expressions of pro-Gaza views as hate, and who routinely target left-wing Jews, were being used as the evidential bedrock to decide who could and couldn't be an MP or councillor.
Finally, there is the human cost. People's lives have been upended, sometimes destroyed, by this tiny ecosystem. It's sometimes caused real pain.
In The Fraud, I used the story of the Jewish Labour Party member Riva Joffe to illustrate this.
Joffe was born to parents who fled antisemitic pogroms in Eastern Europe, and who were forced to flee South Africa (where they had settled) because they became anti-apartheid activists. Joffe became a respected psychoanalyst in the UK.
In 2021, on her deathbed, she was sent a letter by the Labour Party saying she was being investigated for antisemitism. Her "crime" was to share an invite on Facebook to a BDS event at a university.
The complaint was submitted by "David Gordstein" - the made-up identity created by Euan Phillips, a spokesperson for LAAS. Joffe spent her last weeks answering a charge the she was antisemitic, based on a complaint from a made-up identity.
Joffe died while under investigation for antisemitism. The Party refused to tell her son if the case had been resolved after she died.
If you think any of that is OK, then you need to have your head checked.
Seá Noor retweeted
Ran into one of those liberal Zionists who poses as pro-Palestine but spends half their time concern trolling about "antisemitism" in the pro-Palestine movement. He tried to get me to engage him in this subject and I told him this:
Address the fact that 99.9% of the time “antisemitism” gets mentioned it’s in reference to criticisms of Israel and Zionism. Address the fact that Israel and Zionism cause many orders of magnitude more damage than the 0.1% instances of actual antisemitism. Address the fact that the overwhelming majority of the 0.1% instances of actual antisemitism are caused by Israel's genocide and warmongering and would go away if Israel stopped butchering children under the banner of the Star of David. Explain how it is possible to have a “serious discussion about antisemitism” while these three things are happening.
You will answer all four questions I asked you in their entirety if this conversation is to proceed. Until you have thoroughly addressed them all, the conversation you are trying to have is nonsensical.
Seá Noor retweeted
The reason I'm specifically being targeted is because a lot of commentators are angry at me over issues like trans rights and Israel's genocide.
This is opportunistic point scoring - using rape.
It's depraved behaviour, and there's nothing more to say.
Seá Noor retweeted
A group of Israeli settlers have seized eight Palestinian homes on Wednesday in Jericho, located in the occupied West Bank.
Palestinian sources reported that the settlers, accompanied by their families, stormed the eight homes, which were empty at the time of the raid
Seá Noor retweeted
Replying to @LewisJonathanE
You sir are an absolute bigot, This relentless anti Irish campaign to vilify us, is becoming absolutely deplorable. The sheer arrogance of an American lecturing an entire sovereign nation for daring to criticise the Israeli government and stand up for Palestinian human rights is quite extraordinary.
And perhaps the most disgraceful aspect of your entire rant is what you conspicuously fail to mention even once, the suffering of the Palestinian people.
Not a word about the tens of thousands killed in Gaza. Not a word about the children buried beneath rubble, families destroyed, hospitals devastated, mass displacement or the catastrophic humanitarian crisis. Absolutely nothing.
Instead, you and your little groupies on here , concern is apparently Ireland’s criticism of Israel and whether our high-tech economy might suffer as a consequence. What an extraordinary set of priorities.
Let’s establish something you seem determined to ignore. Criticism of the Israeli government is not antisemitism. Supporting Palestinian human rights is not hostility towards Jewish people. Repeating that dishonest conflation doesn’t make it true.
And here’s another distinction. Unlike the United States, Ireland does not have an AIPAC-style political lobbying machine wielding enormous influence over its foreign policy. AIPAC’s political spending and influence in Washington are well documented.
Ireland is perfectly entitled to pursue an independent foreign policy without being subjected to economic scare tactics.
Ireland is a sovereign democracy, not an American subsidiary. We don’t require Washington’s approval to defend international law, condemn the killing of civilians or demand accountability from any government, including Israel’s.
And spare us the suggestion that Ireland’s humanitarian concerns constitute some irrational national obsession. The real question is why our willingness to speak about Palestinian suffering seems to offend you more than the suffering itself.
You managed to write an entire attack on Ireland without expressing a single word of compassion for Palestinian civilians.
That is perhaps the most damning indictment of your argument. Not Ireland’s supposed obsession with Israel, but your extraordinary determination to make Ireland the villain while the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza barely warrants a mention.
You sir might also want to address the uncontrollable antisemitism that’s rife across the US before doing Israel’s bidding to vilify Ireland
Ireland will not be bullied into silence. And nor should it be.
Seá Noor retweeted
On what we’re witnessing among Britain’s liberal commentariat:
For years, debate on Israel was policed by an electric fence. Step beyond the bounds of acceptable opinion and you got a small shock: the insinuation, or the outright charge, of antisemitism. Most people learned where the wire ran and kept inside it.
But now the fence no longer works. We have watched a genocide livestreamed. We have seen what a supremacist ideology has always produced: apartheid, ethnic cleansing, and now genocide. Against that record, the old charge carries no current.
Crucially, the liberal commentariat has not adjusted. They just keep frantically pressing the switch, but the fuse has blown and the shock never comes. The horror this racist ethnostate has produced is now impossible to avoid and the fence is down.
History will not forget those who still stood guard at the fence, or how hard they worked to keep flipping a dud.
Seá Noor retweeted
God help us authors who support Palestine and Palestine Action. Sounds like Adam would have all our books swept off the shelves in a jiffy.
Absolutely vile.
He defames Sally Rooney as antisemitic - for opposing genocide.
He smears the Irish people as a whole.
@adamboultonTABB is a nauseating disgrace
Seá Noor retweeted
Excellent letter from the leader of the Green group in Sheffield.
The Labour Party lost 13 seats and control of the Council in May. If they go ahead with this, they can expect to lose many more next time round.
sheffieldgreenparty.org.uk/2…
Seá Noor retweeted
To be clear, the only reason I was able to reach Heidi was because young Palestinians provided cover with rocks against machine-gun- and tear-gas-wielding settlers and soldiers. It’s those kids, not the settler terrorists, who the IDF was hunting after the attack.
So, it’s going to be a ‘let’s gang up on the Greens, who are never invited, and accuse them of antisemitism, despite their leader being Jewish, while giving the actual racists, Reform, a free pass’ program.
Again.































