dinesh (@dcs62) profile picture

Ex Government of India

NCR
Joined November 2009
Photo by dinesh (@dcs62)Photo by dinesh (@dcs62)
Haha
It is dangerous to joke in India By Justice Katju Although most of my articles and posts are serious, sometimes, to create a lighter atmosphere, I joke too. But joking is dangerous in India, and my habit of joking has often got me into trouble, as most Indians have little or no sense of humour.  and this, too, has contributed to me being described as a 'controversial judge'. m.thewire.in/article/humour/… Consider these examples : (1) I once wrote on my facebook page that since Pakistanis have been adamantly demanding Kashmir for long, we should tell them that they can have it, provided they take Bihar with it too. Now anyone with even a little commonsense would have understood that this was a joke. How can a retired person like me give Bihar to Pakistan ? And Bihar is not contiguous to Pakistan, like Kashmir, Punjab, Gujarat or Rajasthan that it could be given to Pakistan. I also said ( again in  lighter vein ) '' Hindustan ko khatra Pakistan se nahi hai, Bihar se hai ''. Actually these were the words of my English Professor Firaq Gorakhpuri ( the famous Urdu poet ) in the Allahabad University, when I was a student there. It so happened that once Firaq was invited to a mushaira in some city in Bihar. The people in the audience could not understand Urdu, so they hooted him. Being short tempered, Firaq then uttered those words ( which I only repeated in lighter vein ). But the Indian media furiously attacked me, saying I had done  'ghor apmaan' ( great insult ) to Bihar youtube.com/watch?v=p1ASWcXx… youtube.com/watch?v=QSh-Lqbf… youtube.com/watch?v=6k7qnSud… youtube.com/watch?v=TD2grs-y… youtube.com/watch?v=t7iQ5UTp… Biharis got very upset at my statements, and processions were taken out on the streets of many cities of Bihar. In these protests and processions, posters of my face were blackened, and my effigies burnt ( possibly if I had been in Bihar at that time I may have been burnt too ). The Chief Minister of Bihar, Nitish Kumar, castigated me, asking whether I am Bihar's 'mai baap' ? youtube.com/watch?v=a_HLgOwc… An FIR for sedition was also filed against me scroll.in/latest/817730/sedi… During this controversy I was once at the Delhi airport lounge where I met Ms. Meira Kumar, who was the Speaker of the Lok Sabha ( the lower House of Parliament ) and is herself from Bihar. I told her I had only joked about giving Bihar to Pakistan. She smiled at me and said '' Katju saheb, ab aap kuch din Bihar mat jaaiyega '' ( Justice Katju, don't go to Bihar for some time ). Ultimately, following the dictum 'discretion is the better part of valour', and to put a quietus to the matter, I decided to apologize to Biharis (for cracking a joke). (2) After the above incident, some Odiyas asked me to write something about their state Odisha. So I wrote this on my Facebook page: ”I was asked to write about the Oriyas (Odiyas). What is there to write about these poor chaps ? Ever since they got a thrashing at the hands of Emperor Ashoka in the battle of Kalinga about 2300 years ago, they have been a dejected lot. Now all they have with them are a lot of pots (Patras), big pots (Mahapatras), and supposedly intelligent kings (Patnaiks). And of course, they have Lord Jaggannath, to whom they pray every day for revenge on the abominable Biharis. Hari Om P.S. Odiyas, this is just a joke, so don’t file a case against me.” I specifically mentioned at the end of my post that this was just a joke, so that a defamation case is not filed against me ( as had been done in Bihar ). But again there was a hue and cry, this time by Odiyas, for being ‘insulted’. youtube.com/watch?v=3TcojUcn… youtube.com/watch?v=bX2g8FBB… Some Odiya youth of Delhi came to my Noida flat and gave me a 'get well soon' card. ndtv.com/bhubaneshwar-news/o… indiatv.in/india/national-od… Again I beat a hasty retreat and apologised. youtube.com/watch?v=Mo2K5oNI… (3) I once cracked this Sardarji joke on my facebook page : '' A Sardarji was invited to a dinner party. The invitation card mentioned 'Black ties only'. When the Sardarji reached the party he found men wearing shirts and pants also ''. Some Sikhs, on reading this post, filed a petition in the Supreme Court praying for a direction to ban Sardarji jokes, and registering a criminal case against me. The Court referred the matter to Justice HS Bedi, a retired Supreme Court Judge, for his opinion. Justice Bedi, who was himself a Sikh, reported that the petition was frivolous. He said that though a Sikh, he himself often cracked Sardarji jokes. The petition was thereupon dismissed. (4) I once wrote on my fb page ( again as a joke ) that Bengalis should find a good husband for Mamata Banerjee ( the then Chief Minister of West Bengal ), to cool her down. At this Kunal Ghosh, a senior member of Mamata Banerjee's TMC party, commented '' If Justice Katju comes to West Bengal I will slap him on his face ''. (5) A lady lawyer once asked me for some tips how to argue in Court. I said in reply '' Behes karte hue Judge ko aankh maar do '' i.e. '' While arguing, wink at the judge ''. youtube.com/watch?v=Yuxr09uz… ndtv.com/india-news/ex-top-c… youtube.com/watch?v=oJvVcHLo… The consequence was that the Supreme Court Women Lawyers Association called an emergency meeting, in which speaker after speaker roundly condemned me as a misogynist, and stated that such comments were not merely offensive but an assault on the dignity, credibility, competence, integrity and professional standing of every woman in the legal fraternity. The SCWLA demanded my apology, and passed this resolution in the stormy meeting : '' It is deeply disturbing that a former judge of the Supreme Court, who once entrusted with the responsibility of upholding constitutional values, would trivialize the hard work and merit of women lawyers through casual sexism. His words not only demean women advocates but also erode public confidence in the impartiality of the justice system and perpetuate harmful stereotypes that have no place in a democratic society. Coming from a former Judge of the Supreme Court, they are particularly shocking and unbecoming of the dignity associated with constitutional office", I promptly apologised, adding that I had only been joking ndtv.com/india-news/ex-top-c… youtube.com/shorts/ByLCUVxdV… (7) Another example is of a joke I cracked about Chaturvedis. Chaturvedis claim to be Brahmins, but traditionally a Chaturvedi boy can only marry a Chaturvedi girl. Other Brahmins of North India such as Shukla, Mishra, Dwivedi, Trivedi, Pandey, Vajpayi, etc, do not marry a Chaturvedi. So I cracked a joke that Chaturvedis are not Brahmins at all, but are Greeks that have descended from the soldiers of the army of Alexander the Great, who invaded India in 326 B.C. youtube.com/watch?v=zOwp8S3C… youtube.com/watch?v=oJvVcHLo… This created a furore among Chaturvedis all over India who were very upset, and I had to apologize to them, clarifying that I was only joking. To conclude, let me tell this joke on myself. I am a Brahmin, and I once said ”Brahman 60 saal tak ponga rehta hai, aur uske baad sathiya jaata hai.” i.e. A Brahman is a fool till 60, after which he becomes senile. Those Brahmins who have no sense of humor will surely file a defamation case against me. My defense will be that since I am 80, I am senile, and hence non-compos mentis !
1
Ashok Khemka has identified the root of our governance failure. Tukaram Munde is celebrated as a hero simply for enforcing the law. Maharashtra's apparent willingness to let him do his job deserves recognition. How has he escaped the usual pressures—transfers, fabricated complaints or convenient promotions? Give us even ten such officers enforcing laws on FIR registration, police investigations, public health, sanitation and municipal services, backed by firm departmental supervision, and watch public faith in governance returning. We don't lack laws or officers. We lack the will to make ordinary enforcement routine rather than heroic.
A system cannot be considered healthy if an officer needs exceptional courage merely to discharge ordinary responsibilities. Institutional safeguards should make integrity sustainable rather than exceptional.
13
45
1
220
8,304
Not a lawyer but I enjoy reading your experience….
My temptations to file public interest litigations - Desires to become famous overnight - Desires to get established in Legal profession by finding some shortcuts. There is no reason why you should read about my experience unless you are also a struggling first generation lawyer. In 1982, I joined legal profession in Junagadh. I noticed that all other lawyers had “links” through which they were getting their cases. I studied and analysed their links. But all their links were beyond my reach. I was a brief-less first generation lawyers. I had ambitions. I had knowledge. I had merits. But I had no links to get cases. However high I tried to impress a prospective client with my knowledge, he would slip away and would go to some other lawyer. I had no seniors. The seniors were also not interested in me as there were little chances for them to get cases through me. I wanted to file PIL to become famous. But such PILs are filed only in High Court and Supreme Court. I was in district court. How can I become famous? I got connected with some newspapers and started writing articles on latest judgements of Supreme Court. This got me a little fame, but no clients. The fame does not mean automatic flow of clients. Then I felt frustrated. And there is a law of frustration in Universe. Frustration attracts more frustration. This is as certain as the Gravitation Law. I attracted more frustrations in my life. And they don’t give girls to a first generation lawyer who is not earning enough. The question of putting myself up in marriage market was out of question until I had first established myself in a sustainable law practice. The district was also small. There were not enough clients for all members of Bar. Then the temptation to file some public interest case in District Court came. I filed some public interest case without knowing consequences of filing a public interest case. And I also suffered consequences. When you challenge a giant in court, the giant will hire top most lawyer to fight against you but apart from that, he will fight you outside court. He will damage you and your career many ways. To file a public interest case is always like challenging some giant. It is not advisable in early years of law practise. And the frustration that follows is longer than 15 minute of fame in newspapers. The shortcuts in legal profession are not paying. These are usually waste of time and energy. If others had links to get cases, and I did not have links to get cases, then this was my fate. The destiny had served me with a dry plate. And destiny wanted me to wait patiently and to read books of philosophy. The one who has dominants thoughts of sincerely serving litigants, usually starts getting cases. But his thoughts must be honest and strong enough to such an extent that the Universe begins to listen. The Universe does not read newspapers. It listens through our heartbeats. And when the Universe starts responding, the journey begins. If our predominant thoughts are purely selfish, then the journey is harder. #lawyers
1
13
एससी/एसटी एक्ट पर लंबे समय तक बोलता रहा, किसी ने नहीं सुना। लेकिन जैसे ही मोदी एक्ट कहा, सब भन्ना गए। जब परिष्कृत भाषा का कोई असर नहीं हुआ, तो मैंने अपनी भाषा और शैली बदली। आखिर समाज को यह भी सोचना चाहिए कि एक पढ़ा-लिखा व्यक्ति इतनी तल्ख भाषा बोलने को मजबूर क्यों हुआ?
42
1,587
7
4,648
34,792
A system cannot be considered healthy if an officer needs exceptional courage merely to discharge ordinary responsibilities. Institutional safeguards should make integrity sustainable rather than exceptional.
69
546
29
2,858
50,409
The fact that no FIR was registered and no investigation was conducted in Justice Varma's case—where huge volumes of cash went up in flames—is, I believe, the darkest chapter in India's judicial history. The government failed. The Supreme Court failed. The Bar failed. And the press failed. Instead of a police investigation to bring out the truth, what happened was a mockery—conducted initially by a committee appointed by the Chief Justice of India, and then by another committee appointed by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha under the Judges (Inquiry) Act. Both of these committee reports indicted Justice Varma. That may offer some consolation, but the damage caused to the Indian judiciary is irreparable. I had moved the Supreme Court for the fourth time a year ago, and I mentioned the matter—my petition seeking the registration of an FIR and an investigation—before the Honorable Chief Justice on the very same day he assumed office. Thereafter, I mentioned the matter a couple of times. Whenever I did, I am afraid to say that instead of answering my plea to list the case, the court muted the video. However, what is past is past and done. My aim here is not to blame anybody. The injustice has to be undone, and the wrong has to be corrected. The reports of the two committees are available in the public domain—or at least, I have copies of both reports. I would like to pursue the matter to ensure that an FIR is registered and the criminal law is set in motion. I call upon one and all—all right-thinking people in this country—to join me. I can be contacted via my email and mobile, which are available in the public domain at Nedumpara.com.
36
218
10
702
10,799
"मैं सवर्ण हूं, मैं संवैधानिक अछूत हूं! मैं बोलना चाहता हूं सारी पार्टियों से की हमको जहर दे दें, हम मृत्यु स्वीकार कर लेंगे! और भाजपा सरकार सुन ले, उसको तो उखाड़ फेंकेंगे" -UP RSS का सवर्ण कार्यकर्ता जमीन पर हद नाराजगी है! लेकिन ये लोग अभी भी जाग नहीं रहे! खैर हमको क्या, हम तो हजार किलोमीटर दूर बैठे हैं! उत्तरप्रदेश वाले जाने! 😂😂😂
101
2,404
67
6,315
64,823
BJP should be judged not based on its public speeches, but based on what it does in court & on ground. UGC brought a wave of awareness amongst GCs, & then this wave was followed by a tsunami of awareness. Now ppl are going back & searching things. & They are finding things, which has made them realize that they have been fooled over yrs. This has led to a sense of betrayal, amongst GCs.
101
1,720
28
4,216
43,085
A cogent submission Sir..@mkatju
The law of contempt of court in India needs to be revisited By Justice Katju The Supreme Court on Wednesday, November 18, 2026 issued notice on a petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association seeking initiation of contempt proceedings against a lawyer, Pravin Singhal, for allegedly making disparaging remarks about Chief Justice of India, Justice Surya Kant, in open court. Do disparaging remarks against a judge in court amount to contempt of court ? To answer this question it is necessary to delve deep into the issue. The present law of contempt of court in India is a hangover of the original law on this subject in England.This law originated from an undelivered judgment of J Wilmot in 1765, where the judge said the power of contempt of court was necessary to maintain the dignity and majesty of judges and vindicate their authority. But whence comes this dignity, majesty and authority of judges? In England, in feudal times, it came from the king, who was the fountain of justice, and would often decide cases himself. Later, when he had many other duties, he delegated judicial functions to his delegates, who were called judges. Thus, in a monarchy, the judge really exercises the sovereign function of the king, which has been delegated to him by the latter, and for this he requires the dignity, authority and majesty which a king must have, to secure obedience. In feudal times, the king was supreme, and the people were his subjects. They could not criticize him, and such criticism was punishable. The Judges, who performed the delegated functions of the king, could also therefore not be criticised, since criticising them amounted to criticism of the king, and was therefore a crime In a democracy, like India, however, this relationship is reversed. Now it is the people, not a king, who are supreme, and all state authorities, including judges, are nothing but their servants. The Preamble to the Indian Constitution uses the words " We the people of India '', and states that India is a democracy and a republic. This makes it clear that it is the Indian people who are supreme in India, not any state authority. It follows that the British law of contempt of court is obsolete, antiquated, and outdated in independent India, but surprisingly it has been continued. In a democracy there is no need for judges to vindicate their authority or display pomp and majesty. Their authority comes not from fear of contempt but from the public confidence, and this in turn depends on their own conduct, integrity, impartiality, and learning. This view is accepted now even in England. As observed by Lord Salmon in AG vs BBC (1981) A.C. 303, “The description contempt of court no doubt has a historical basis, but it is nevertheless misleading. Its object is not to protect the dignity of the court, but to protect the administration of justice”. “Justice is not a cloistered virtue,” said Lord Atkin. “It must suffer the scrutiny and outspoken comments of ordinary men”. In R. Vs. Commr. of Police (1968) 2 QB 150 Lord Denning observed, “Let me say at once that we will never use this jurisdiction to uphold our own dignity. That must rest on surer foundations. Nor will we use it to suppress those who speak against us. We do not fear criticism, nor do we resent it. For there is something far more important at stake. It is no less than freedom of speech itself. All that we ask is that those who criticize us should remember that, from the nature of our duties, we cannot reply to their criticism. We cannot enter into public controversy. We must rely on our conduct itself to be its own vindication”. Sometimes an upright judge is unjustifiably criticized. The best course of action for such a judge is to ignore baseless criticism (but pay heed to honest and correct criticism). He should have broad enough shoulders to shrug off baseless comments without getting perturbed or influenced. Once a British newspaper ran a banner headline calling the majority judges of the House of Lords who decided the Spycatcher case ( Attorney General vs. Guardian Newspaper, 1987 3 AllE.R.316) “YOU FOOLS”. Fali Nariman, who was present in England at that time, asked Lord Templeman, who was one of the majority, why the Judges did not take contempt action. Lord Templeman smiled, and said that judges in England took no notice of personal insults. Although he did not regard himself as a fool, others were entitled to their opinion. In Balogh vs Crown Court at Albon (1975) AC 373, the defendant told the Judge “You are a humourless automaton. Why don’t you self destruct?”. The judge smiled, but took no action. Now coming to the law of contempt in India, we find it is uncertain. Nariman described it in a speech as ‘Dog’s Law’. He quoted Bentham, who said that when a dog does something nasty we beat him for it. Similarly, the laws in England become known only when someone is punished by the courts. The same is true about the law of contempt in India, and thus it is a standing threat to freedom of speech. To illustrate, in Duda’s case AIR 1988 SC 1208, a Union Cabinet minister said that the Supreme Court sympathized with zamindars and bank magnates. He further said, “FERA violators, bride burners, and a whole horde of reactionaries have found their haven in the Supreme Court” and that Supreme Court judges have “unconcealed sympathy for the haves”. No action was taken against him. Nariman asked whether if such a comment had been made by an ordinary man the court would have taken no action. Moreover, in an earlier decision, in the case of Namboodiripad (former CM of Kerala), who accused Supreme Court judges of being biased in favour of the rich, (an allegation similar to that of the Union minister in Duda’s case) the court convicted Namboodiripad for contempt (AIR 1770 2015). Where is the certainty or consistency in the law ? We have two provisions in our Constitution, Article 19(1)(a) which gives citizens freedom of speech, and Articles 129 and 215 which give the Supreme Court and High Court the power of contempt. How are these provisions to be reconciled. In my opinion, since Article 19(1)(a) is the right of the people who are supreme in a democracy, while Articles 129 and 215 are powers of judges, who are servants of the people, the reconciliation can only be done by holding that freedom of speech is primary, while the contempt power is only secondary. It follows that the contempt power cannot be exercised because people are criticizing a judge. It can only be exercised if someone makes the functioning of the judge impossible e.g. if while a judge is hearing a case someone jumps on to the dias and tries to run away with the court file, or if he attacks or threatens a witness. If someone calls a judge a fool inside the courtroom and goes away, in my opinion it is not contempt, for he has not stopped the functioning of the court. But if he keeps shouting in court the whole day, and despite warnings does not stop, he is obviously not letting the court function, and this would be contempt. After all disputes in society have to be adjudicated, and judges must decide cases to justify payment of salaries to them. I submit that the time has come now for Parliament, the judiciary and others concerned to take a fresh look at the law of contempt of court in the light of what I have said above, and bring about necessary amendments. The great judge Jerome Frank, in his book Courts on Trial, said he had little patience with, or respect for, the view that it is dangerous to tell the public unpalatable truths about the judiciary. He wrote: “I am unable to conceive that in a democracy, it can ever be unwise to acquaint the public with the truth about the workings of any branch of government. It is wholly undemocratic to treat the public as children who are unable to accept the inescapable shortcomings of man-made institutions… The best way to bring about the elimination of those shortcomings of our judicial system which are capable of being eliminated is to have all our citizens informed as to how that system now functions. It is a mistake, therefore, to try to establish and maintain, through ignorance, public esteem for our courts.” I submit that now the time has come to reconsider and change the law of contempt of court, and make it in accordance with democracy. People should have the right to criticize judges, and if the criticism is unfounded, the remedy for the judge should be to file a suit for defamation
12
ऐसा है बालियान जी, थोड़ा जानकारी बढ़ाएं - 1. कर्नाटक में भी बढ़े हुए आरक्षण के खिलाफ हम ही सुप्रीम कोर्ट गये हैं! 2. रोहित वेमुला बिल के खिलाफ भी पिछले साल से हमीं लिख रहे हैं, जबकि भाजपा मुंह में दही जमाए बैठी है! बाकी ऐसे ही धमकियां देते रहिए और लोगों को IT सेल का असल चेहरा दिखाते रहिए🙏
ऐसा है नेहा जी, अब आप भी तैयार रहिए। हम हिंदुत्व और राष्ट्रवाद की IT सेल है तो आप जातिवाद की IT सेल ही जिसका काम सिर्फ लोगो को भिड़ाना है और जिसे अपनी जाति से अलग कुछ नहीं दिखता। बंगलौर में जहाँ बैठे हो वही पर सामान्य वर्ग से जुड़े कई मुद्दे है, उसी कर्नाटक में विशेष आरक्षण भी दिया जा रहा है और सामान्य वर्ग के ख़िलाफ़ रोहित वेणुला एक्ट भी लाया जा रहा है। कभी अपनी ये क्रांति जहाँ रहती हो उस राज्य में करके देखिएगा। पता चल जाएगा कि सरकार क्या होती। और सुन लो, “अब बहुत हुआ सम्मान…….” मोड ऑन हो चुका है, बर्दाश्त नहीं कर पाओगे आप अगले रिप्लाई। बेहतर है अपने जातिवादी वाले मुद्दे पर फोकस करो, यहाँ से दूर रहो।
92
993
10
2,705
20,103
खुरपेंच FSSAI में स्वीटी बेहरा की Director पद पर नियुक्ति को लेकर सवाल उठाए थे। मार्च 2026 में खुरपेंच के खिलाफ FIR भी दर्ज कर दी गई। भर्ती से जुड़े रिकॉर्ड में पात्रता और नियमों में दी गई छूट को लेकर गंभीर सवाल उठते हैं। फिर भी इन कथित विसंगतियों पर अब तक कोई कार्रवाई क्यों नहीं हुई? आखिर जवाबदेही किसकी है और जिम्मेदार अधिकारियों पर कार्रवाई कब होगी?
1
57
1
144
2,369
Justice Gavai was after Justice Chandrachud’s ass regarding the vacating of the official residence post-retirement. Meanwhile, he is still occupying his official bungalow on Tughlaq road for almost a year after demitting office. How cute! 🥺
Last night at Justice Gavai’s…
52
589
27
4,352
98,922
आर्काइव | मोदी के शासनकाल में न्यायपालिका का पूरी तरह रूपांतरण हुआ है. अपने पहले कार्यकाल में कार्यपालिका ने आहिस्ता-आहिस्ता अदालतों का घेराव किया और मोदी के दुबारा चुने जाने के बाद इस पर धावा बोल दिया गया. सुप्रीम कोर्ट, जिसका मकसद जनता के अधिकारों की रक्षा करना था, उसकी ख्याति अब सरकार की इच्छाओं का चैंपियन बनना है. सहारा-बिड़ला डायरी में कथित तौर पर कॉरपोरेट घरानों द्वारा मोदी तथा अन्य राजनीतिज्ञों को दी जाने वाली धनराशि का ब्यौरा था लेकिन जब अदालत से कहा गया कि इसकी जांच का आदेश जारी करे तो उसने साफ तौर पर कह दिया कि इसकी कोई जरूरत नहीं है. अमित शाह के खिलाफ हत्या के एक मामले की जांच करने वाले न्यायाधीश बी एच लोया की अचानक हुई मृत्यु के बाद अदालत ने सरकार की इस बात से ही खुद को संतुष्ट कर लिया कि कहीं कुछ भी गलत नहीं हुआ है. ऐसा ही मुद्दा एलेक्टोलर बांड्स का था जिसके जरिए बीजेपी को गुप्त दान के रूप में अपार धनराशि की प्राप्ति हुई लेकिन इस मामले में भी अदालत ने इसके संवैधानिक होने की जांच की अपनी न्यायिक जिम्मेदारी को भी ताक पर रख दिया . 2019 में मोदी के दोबारा चुने जाने के बाद से सरकार ने ज्यादातर मामलों में - खासतौर पर कश्मीर के मामले में ऐसा काम किया है जैसे वह किसी भी संवैधानिक बाध्यता के प्रति उत्तरदायी नहीं है. अदालतों में और खासतौर पर सुप्रीम कोर्ट में नरेन्द्र मोदी का चेहरा तुषार मेहता हैं. 2014 में मोदी के प्रधानमंत्री बनने के कुछ ही समय बाद अतिरिक्त सॉलिसीटर जनरल के पद पर मेहता की नियुक्ति हुई और सरकार का पक्ष रखने के लिए वह कतार तोड़कर सबसे आगे आ गए. 2017 में जब उनके पूर्ववर्ती सॉलिसीटर जनरल ने इस्तीफा दे दिया तो सरकार ने एक वर्ष तक इस पद पर किसी की नियुक्ति नहीं की जबकि दो अन्य असिस्टेंट सॉलिसीटर जनरल के अंदर हताशा का भाव पैदा हो रहा था क्योंकि उन्होंने मेहता के मुकाबले ज्यादा समय तक सेवाएं दी थीं. अक्टूबर 2018 में इन दोनों व्यक्तियों पी॰ एस॰ नरसिम्हा और मनिंदर सिंह ने एक के बाद एक इस्तीफा दे दिया. सिंह ने उसी दिन इस्तीफा दिया जिस दिन मेहता को सॉलिसीटर जनरल बनाया गया. मेहता का उदय एक बड़ी योजना का हिस्सा हैः राष्ट्रीय दृश्य पटल पर आने के बाद मोदी सरकार का अपनी सत्ता को सुदृढ़ करना और इस सत्ता का विस्तार अदालतों तक ले जाना. मोदी के सबसे बड़े सहयोगी और मौजूदा गृह मंत्री अमित शाह के विश्वास पात्र के रूप में मेहता उस समय से ही हैं जब से गुजरात में इस सदी की शुरूआत में दोनों की मुलाकात हुई. भारत की राजनीति में अब तक के सर्वाधिक विवादास्पद राजनीतिक जीवन के धनी अमित शाह की जिंदगी के हर उतार चढ़ाव में मेहता उनके साथ खड़े रहे हैं और मेहता की खुद की किस्मत इन राजनीतिज्ञों की किस्मत के साथ आगे बढ़ती रही है. पढ़ें अतुल देव का पूरा लेख : hindi.caravanmagazine.in/law… कारवां की ईमानदार और निष्पक्ष रिपोर्टिंग को सब्सक्राइब करें और हमारा सहयोग करें
2
64
3
138
2,912
As long as I have known @neha_laldas, I can confidently say that her research, data skills and her perseverance are pretty good. The whole chatua giroh can’t do a thing to her on data and facts. All they can do is blabber. She and YFE are fighting against reservation in courts across India. Chatua giroh knows only one thing: try hard to pull us down via traditional (trolling) means. If she responds to you, take it as a compliment because most of you don’t deserve to be replied to. Take as long as you all can, come after each one of us, one thing is guaranteed: We will make you eat shit. Wait and watch.
58
1,437
7
5,422
86,431
To be honest, I did not have a particularly good experience appearing before him. I appeared before Justice Anil Kshetarpal in several matters before the Delhi High Court, particularly in service matters, CAT appeals and when he was presiding over the GST Bench. In a number of writ petitions, I witnessed that the matters were dismissed simply because an alternative remedy was available. In doing so, the constitutional issues raised and the settled law on the subject were, in my view, not given due consideration. The law laid down by the Supreme Court in Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks, (1998) 8 SCC 1, and Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2021) 6 SCC 771 is quite clear. Availability of an alternative remedy does not bar the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226. There are well-recognised exceptions, particularly where a petition raises issues concerning enforcement of fundamental rights, violation of principles of natural justice, lack of jurisdiction or challenge to the vires of a legislation. In two of my matters, which were dismissed on the ground of alternative remedy, I approached the Supreme Court by way of SLPs. The Court issued notice in both matters on the basis of the pleadings itself, without requiring me to make oral submissions at that stage. I am sure many advocates who have appeared before him would have their own experiences. I would not be surprised if quite a few are happy with his retirement. However, this post is not about an individual judge or his retirement. It is about something I have always felt strongly about. A judge may agree or disagree with an advocate. A petition may ultimately be dismissed, and an argument may not find favour with the Court. That is part of litigation. But what matters is whether the advocate has been heard patiently and whether the issues raised have actually been examined. More so in writ jurisdiction, where the High Court is exercising its constitutional powers under Article 226. The availability of an alternative remedy cannot become a convenient ground to dismiss a petition without examining whether the case falls within the recognised exceptions. As advocates, we do not expect the Court to agree with everything we argue. But we do expect to be heard, and we do expect the law and judgments cited before the Court to be considered. For me, that is as important as knowing the law itself…
23
18
4
139
11,978
अभिषेक जी, कितनी बार बोला है थोड़ा अच्छे से डेटा पढ़ा करो फिर जवाब देने आया करो! हमको बार-बार आपको सही करना अच्छा नहीं लगता, लेकिन आप चले आते हो आधा अधूरा ज्ञान लेकर पार्टी चाटुकारिता निभाने! अब सुनो, 1. AISHE report में प्राइवेट यूनिवर्सिटी का भी डाटा है, सिर्फ सरकारी यूनिवर्सिटी का नहीं! वहां भी SC/ST/OBC छात्र 60% से अधिक हैं! और ये सिर्फ self disclosed information है, यानी असलियत में कहीं ज्यादा होंगे! (Pic 1) 2. जो professional courses (medical, engineering, MBA, Law वगैरह) का आप ज़िक्र कर रहे ना, वहां भी आरक्षण भयंकर हो गया है और वहां भी सवर्ण घटते जा रहे हैं! ये डाटा भी उसी AISHE रिपोर्ट में था जिसको आप पढ़ना भूल गए! (Pic 2) 3. सरकारी छोड़ो, प्राइवेट में जाओ - ये क्या लॉजिक है?? हम यहां स्कूल नहीं, कॉलेज की बात कर रहे हैं, जहां career बनता है! आप बोल रहे हैं कि सारे सवर्ण अब प्राइवेट यूनिवर्सिटी में जाकर मेडिकल, इंजीनियरिंग करें और IIT/IIM/AIIMS और अन्य सरकारी संस्थाओं का मोह छोड़ दें? मतलब इसका कोई तुक है? और आपको किसने बता दिया कि सवर्ण सिर्फ प्राइवेट में पढ़ते हैं?? मैं भी बिहार से हूं और सरकारी कॉलेज से ही पढ़ाई की है, बाकायदा entrance clear कर के! तो मुझे मत सिखाइए! और प्लीज, बिहार का नाम मत डुबाइए 🙏
Replying to @neha_laldas
@neha_laldas सम्मान के साथ बोलूँगा आपके आँकड़े डरवाने अवश्य है किंतु सत्य नहीं है ।
162
1,061
25
2,578
30,855
There are only two ways to end caste politics: 1. Make all government policies caste-neutral. 2. Include all castes in every government policy. Suvendu Adhikari opted for the second approach, marking a new beginning in politics.
80
1,149
16
5,493
50,547
इनका नाम नेहा लालदास है GC एक्टिविस्ट हैं इस अकेली औरत से बीजेपी के बड़े बड़े ITcell धुरंधर पानी मांग रहे हैं पर गज़ब की हिम्मती महिला है,सिस्टम से लड़ना सबके बस की बात नहीं होती इनकी जिंदगी में काफ़ी परेशानियाँ आ रही होंगी, बावजूद इसके ये हमारे लिए लड़ रही हैं. सैलूट बहन🙏
138
1,528
43
5,575
38,449
Cuál deberías tomar en cada caso: Toma PARACETAMOL para: - Dolor de cabeza sin inflamación - Fiebre y escalofríos por gripe - Dolor de garganta - Dolor cuando tienes el estómago vacío o lo tienes sensible Toma IBUPROFENO para: - Golpes, esguinces y articulaciones inflamadas - Dolor de muelas - Dolor menstrual - Contracturas y dolor de espalda
26
245
6
2,672
491,211
ब्रो का नाम दीपक मिश्रा है ब्रो गांजा रखवाने में बहुत तेज है💀💀
आप सबको बहुत दुख के साथ सूचित करना पड़ रहा है, होटल में छापामार युद्ध के दौरान किसी को गांजे के केस में फंसाने वाले ASP खुद सस्पेंड हो गए 💀
167
3,137
33
11,452
261,605