Catherine Mary retweeted
This series of events is very important to note because, *mark my words, it’s happening again*
GIDS 2005; 2019 and now 2026.
All ideologically invested in the idea that a small number of children need to medically transition. And with divining rod therapy, they believe some
Thanks, @Glinner. I hope you don’t mind me going back over some of the history. It shows some of the difficulties we’ve faced: our attempts to understand and protect young people have been misrepresented as bigotry, and honest dialogue has been shut down since the beginning.
Sue @sueevansprotect blew the whistle in 2005. She was warning that young people with serious comorbid problems were being rushed into a medical pathway with very little psychological assessment. David Taylor, then medical director at the Tavistock, asked Jim McKeith to investigate GIDS. Taylor wrote a highly critical report in 2006. I was part of the senior management team, but its findings were never discussed there. The Trust buried it.
In 2019, I resigned as a governor because I realised history was in danger of repeating itself. The Trust was trying to bury David Bell’s report, which raised similar concerns to those Sue had raised in 2005.
That year I spoke alongside Stephanie Davies-Arai @cwknews and others at a House of Lords event organised by Posie Parker’s group, Standing for Women @StandingforXX and sponsored by Lord Moonie @Moonie_l Afterwards, we met in the pub to discuss what to do when there is a failure of medical authority. That was where the plan was hatched for Sue and Mrs A, the mother of an autistic child on the GIDS waiting list, to bring a judicial review. Sue put the case together with Paul Conrathe. Keira Bell @KBtheYoungOG was initially a witness in the case and later became a claimant.
While I was being interviewed by the Panorama team about GIDS in 2019, I told them about Taylor’s report. Hannah Barnes @hannahsbee was part of the team and later obtained the report through a Freedom of Information request. In September 2020, NHS England commissioned Hilary Cass @Hilary_Cass to lead an independent review of gender identity services for children and young people. The review account is @TheCassReview.
Newsnight reported on Taylor’s report on 1 October 2020. It showed that many of the concerns later raised in David Bell’s report had already been identified: a lack of critical clinical thinking, too little attention to the possible downsides of treatment, and little interest in follow-up or research. In other words, there was a lack of appropriate clinical curiosity. The High Court later ruled in the claimants’ favour, but the Court of Appeal overturned that ruling in 2021.
As I argued in my first paper, “Freedom to Think”, published in the Psychiatric Bulletin, clinicians need to be free to think, even when a patient may fear that thinking will introduce doubt and conflict. Thinking can be painful. It can bring anxiety and doubt in place of certainty. But it is crucial because it also protects us against misadventure. The wish to shut down discussion and thought is still represented in the Conversion Practices Bill. We are still fighting to bring to light what is happening in this clinical area and to stop a Bill that would have a chilling effect on clinicians’ ability to explore and thoroughly assess what is going on with these young people. @SexMattersOrg @Transgendertrd @genspect @CanSG_org #ConversionPracticesBill
Catherine Mary retweeted
If you're a lawyer (barrister, solicitor, pupil barrister, trainee solicitor, judge or legal academic) and interested in the legal issues relating to sex, gender identity and gender reassignment, please join the Sex and Gender Law Association. Link in next post.
Catherine Mary retweeted
“Have you recently been outed as a s*x pest?”
I obviously can't say for sure who was the inspiration behind this sketch from series three of Tracey Ullman’s Show (2016 - 2018), but I can certainly shadow a guess!
She really is bloody good, don’t you think?
By the way, did you know that The Simpsons began life as a series of animated shorts that were broadcast between sketches on The Tracey Ullman Show, way back in 1987.
Catherine Mary retweeted
Calling UK lawyers!
Membership now open for the Sex & Gender Law Association
For practising, academic & retired lawyers, judges, pupils & trainees
SaGLA is non-partisan. You don't have to hold any particular view to join
No joining fee (for now)
🔗 sagla.substack.com/p/join-th…
Catherine Mary retweeted
Now the Pope has warned about transhumanism why not read about the trans identified billionaire who is trying to replace humans with cyborgs? 'Martine' Rothblatt runs his own cult and created a robot version of his wife. Click on the link in my bio to read his shocking story. 👆
Hoy se multiplican las promesas del transhumanismo y del posthumanismo: son corrientes ideológicas, según las cuales —antes o después— la tecnología eliminará toda enfermedad o dolor, así como el envejecimiento e incluso la propia muerte. Precisamente porque el progreso en las ciencias es un óptimo fruto de la inteligencia humana, no se confunde con un privilegio para millonarios que pretenden la inmortalidad, mientras que pueblos enteros sufren miseria y opresión. Se nos vende, así, la ilusión de seres humanos optimizados por la cibernética y la biotecnología. Frente a este espejismo, la antropología cristiana recuerda que el límite no es un defecto de fábrica, sino la condición de la grandeza humana. #ViajeApostólico #Perú #MagnificaHumanitas vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/e…
“Trans women are women”. “No debate”. I despise @stonewalluk with a passion I never knew was in me.
Described as a "vulnerable young lady" by his KC, this would-be-serial killer was at least seen for what he was by the judge. I was in court to witness him being sentenced:
dailymail.com/news/article-1…
1
56
👀👀👀👀
1
1
28
Replying to @KonstantinKisin
Air traffic controllers talk to pilots over radio frequencies. A widespread technical problem is knocking out those radio channels (and possibly some radar) across multiple FAA centers.
To keep everyone safe, the FAA ordered a nationwide ground stop: no more planes can take off from US airports until further notice. Planes already flying can still land. International arrivals are handled one by one.
They do not yet know the exact cause or how long it will last.
Oh Scotland. 😳 From 2019.
Replying to @caithness_pf
So I had a search..
First survey form 2010 by the now disbanded Women’s National Commission which included 650 UK women’s sector orgs.
web.archive.org/web/20110818…
It found that 99% (of the 297 women-only service users and providers asked) value women-only services:
1
55
Catherine Mary retweeted
This clip from the @SP_Equalities meeting yesterday demonstrates clearly what is going wrong in @ScotParl. The politicians don't understand the law. But look at the Convenors final hand gesture to @MForstater - Wheesht! My advice to the Committee, try reading the FWS judgment. 🤷♀️
Catherine Mary retweeted
Can you name all 59 women who came forward against Cosby? Can you name half of them? Can you name 5? Would you recognize them out of context? Do you want an autograph?
Cool so we agree that women don’t make rape accusations to become famous.
I’m so excited I think I might throw up
Mother of God... Here's your first look at Line of Duty series 7, coming next year!
See more ➡️ bbc.in/4BSnHjT
1
47
Catherine Mary retweeted
Looking for one male dancer for approx two weeks work in February 2026 in a UK-Japan co-production residency. Please share.
Catherine Mary retweeted
This Thurs 12 Nov at 11.15am Clinical Psychologist Anna Hutchinson will speak at the Pre-Legislative Scrutiny Committee. Watch online👇parliamentlive.tv/Event/Inde…
Here's Anna at our 2024 @UKLabour conference fringe on the harms of a Conversion Practices Bill👇
youtu.be/fMFSjnndN-w?si=BLBE…
Catherine Mary retweeted
Parents of ROGD kids recently surpassed 3,500 members – certainly not a milestone to celebrate, but validation that connecting with others in your community who are also navigating gender dysphoria with their children can provide some comfort during an otherwise overwhelming and isolating situation. If you’re a parent of a child who has come out as transgender, asking to be medicalized, etc., reach out to us and we will connect you to a support group in your area: parentsofrogdkids.com/
Catherine Mary retweeted
If you want to know why the trans lobby is so misogynistic and homophobic the answer lies in its origin story. No social justice movement in history has more embarrassing roots or dodgier founders. 👇👇👇
1./ What's the truth about the rise of the modern trans movement? Behind the largely fictional official tale there's a stranger, more interesting reality. There's a glimpse of it in this gem from the BBC archive; the first TV show made by transsexuals.👇
bbc.co.uk/programmes/p06c83f…
Catherine Mary retweeted
A reminder that Stonewall actively supported conversion practices.
Replying to @akuareindorf
2/ So a transbian isn’t a lesbian under the #ConversionBill. If he abusively tries to pressure a lesbian into sex, causing her serious alarm or distress, in principle that could be an abusive conversion practice if he’s intending to cause her to change her sexual orientation>































