Hamish retweeted
Oct 7 was clarifying for me. As @DouglasKMurray said it was like a flare went up and you could see where everyone was standing.
Hamish retweeted
A Statement of Conscience on October 7
I will not start by saying âas a Muslimâ or âas an imamâ, but as a human being.
On October 7, over 1,200 innocent people were killed in a single day. Families were shot in their homes. Young people out dancing were hunted across open fields. Over 250 people, including children and the elderly, were dragged into Gaza as hostages. I think of a mother hiding in a safe room with her babyâs mouth covered. I think of a father listening as the line went quiet. I think of families who waited month after month for someone to come home, only to receive a coffin. I didnât need my faith to recognize the evil of what happened. My heart told me first.
But Iâm a Muslim and an imam, and I owe the world one honest sentence: what was done that day was a crime against God. God teaches that whoever kills one innocent soul, it is as if he had killed all humanity.
This day has an author: Yahya Sinwar. He planned it, ordered it, and knew what would follow. Every death of that day and war he started rests on him and Hamas leaders who sat in tunnels and foreign hotels and called slaughter a victory. It rests on every Palestinian leader who cheered, excused, handed out sweets, or said nothing. They chose this. They own it.
But Sinwar did not invent himself. He was the fruit of a tree planted almost a century ago by the Muslim Brotherhood. Hamas named itself in its founding charter as the Brotherhoodâs branch in Palestine. The Brotherhoodâs poison is slow. It arrives through study circles, youth camps, charity boxes, and kind words to lonely young men. Drop by drop, it teaches him that his religion is a political party, his neighbour is his enemy, the Jew is the cause of his sorrow, and God is pleased by rage. By the time the gun arrives, the soul is already taken.
I have seen this poison in mosques where sermons became rallies and young men could recite slogans but not sit still for a verse on mercy. Every people that let the Brotherhood in has paid in blood and ruined generations. It has never built anything it did not first set on fire.
Behind Hamas stands another hand: the IRGC. It was the IRGCâs money, weapons, and training that turned a hateful idea into an army. One calls itself Sunni and the other Shia, and they may curse each otherâs creeds, but they are united in what they worship. It is not God. It is power. The same IRGC that armed the killers of October 7 shoots Iranian girls for showing their hair, hangs young men for asking to be free, and has left graves from Tehran to Damascus to Beirut. They speak in Godâs name. So did Pharaoh speak in the name of heaven.
So let me say this clearly. Hamas and the IRGC are not merely enemies of Islam. That would be too small a charge, as if their crime were only against us. They are enemies of God. God is the Giver of life, yet they deal in death. God calls Himself the Most Merciful, yet they have made cruelty a sacrament. God honoured the children of Adam, yet they look at a child and see a target or a shield. To murder what God created and sign His name to it is the oldest blasphemy.
And we Muslims have been too quiet. Some of us were afraid. Some told ourselves it was not our business. Some, God forgive them, felt something other than horror that morning and never confessed it. Silence was the soil this poison grew in. I will not add to it.
So on this anniversary, let us say plainly what our scripture already says. The Jews are not our enemies. They are our cousins in Abraham, and their dead were created by the same God who created us. Today belongs to them: the murdered, the hostages, and families who still set a place at the table. To them I say: I am sorry for what was done to you by men who used the words of my prayers. Youâre not alone in your grief or remembrance.
The enemies of God are those who murder in His name. We know their names. It is time we said them from our own pulpits, in our own voices, before they speak for us again.
Imam Tawhidi
Hamish retweeted
Is âPakistanismâ racism? Itâs a state formed at the same time as Israel. It discriminates & dispossesses, & has done for decades. It was responsible for a conflict far more deadly than Gaza, labelled as a genocide by many. Yet there isnât a global movement to end it as a state.
Hamish retweeted
What if there were calls for widespread protests in support of the 9/11 hijackers, three years after 3,000 Americans were murdered? What if tens of thousands rallied for the Nazis on the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz?
No one would need to be told how obscene that was.
Yet here is a flyer for a "citywide protest" at New York's City Hall on October 7, three years to the day after the worst slaughter of Jews since the Holocaust. It promises "glory to the martyrs, victory to the resistance."
And there are dozens of rallies planned across America and European cities and campuses.
Pick that date, put a masked figure at the center of the poster, and promise victory to "the resistance," and you've told everyone whose side you are on.
What they are celebrating is not hard to reconstruct.
On October 7, Hamas terrorists went house to house in the kibbutzim. They broke into safe rooms and set homes on fire to drive families out. Infants, children, and people in their 80s and 90s were killed in their beds and in their safe rooms. At the Nova festival, they hunted people across open fields for hours, shot those hiding in bomb shelters and under vehicles, raped and mutilated, and took captives.
After 9/11, America said you are either with us or against us. The line seemed clear. You stood for the West and what it represents, or you stood with a nihilistic religious extremism that wanted to replace it with a medieval theocracy.
That line has been blurred by a generation raised on an oppressor/oppressed script, by Gulf money flowing into our universities, and by a media and political class that has decided criticizing the killers, the extremists, the Islamists, is somehow intolerant.
So tomorrow, neighbors, our students, people we work beside, will rally to honor the mass murder of that day.
I'm sorry if this sounds grim. For those of us commemorating the memory of the victims, it is a disgraceful inversion of fact and history.
Hamish retweeted
The Green Partyâs decision to pass a motion treating Zionism as a form of racism is the latest manifestation of a much bigger and more disturbing trend in modern politics.
I increasingly think social media has done something profound to the way human beings form political beliefs.
Algorithms donât simply give us access to more information. They learn what engages us and then repeatedly feed us variations of it. We click on something because it confirms a suspicion, and the machine gives us more. Then more again.
Over time, beliefs that once seemed extreme can begin to feel completely normal.
Iâve watched intelligent, liberal, reasonable people move from legitimate concern about Israelâs treatment of Palestinians to casually saying they wouldnât care if Israel disappeared altogether because they now regard it as an inherently murderous or illegitimate state.
I think something similar has happened in the gender debate. People who once regarded womenâs sex-based rights and safeguarding as fundamental now argue that those protections should give way to gender identity - while remaining convinced that they are simply becoming more compassionate.
That is the part that fascinates and worries me most.
People rarely experience ideological radicalisation as radicalisation. From inside their own heads, it feels like moral progress.
And social media is uniquely equipped to accelerate that process because the information reaching us is no longer primarily information we have consciously gone looking for. Increasingly, the machine chooses it for us - one post, video and outrage at a time.
Perhaps the biggest mistake governments make is imagining this is principally a problem affecting children.
Adults are susceptible too.
X, TikTok, Facebook, YouTube and the rest are conducting an unprecedented experiment on billions of human minds. None of us should assume we are immune simply because we consider ourselves intelligent, liberal, conservative, compassionate or well informed.
The most important political habit of the next decade may therefore be intellectual self-surveillance. Ask yourself:
Why do I believe this?
Did I always believe it?
What evidence would change my mind?
And is my worldview actually mine - or has an algorithm been quietly constructing it for me?
Because if we cannot answer those questions, polarisation is going to get much worse before it gets better.
Hamish retweeted
Some numbers tell a dispositive story.
1939: 40 million Arabs in the world.
2026: 450 million Arabs in the world
1939: 17 million Jews in the world.
2026: 16 million Jews in the world
1939: 4 sovereign Arab states
2026: 22 sovereign Arab states
1939: 0 sovereign Jewish states.
2026: 1 sovereign Jewish state
Tell me again what the argument is about.
Hamish retweeted
Lots of @TheGreenParty officials posting about how they âdonât agreeâ with the motion.
We are often asked: âWhat would you have done when they came for the Jews?â
Well, your party just did.
So either own it or leave it.
Enough with the empty posturing.
Hamish retweeted
Replying to @carla_denyer
Tell you what. Get your Muslim members to promise they will never attend a mosque that criticises homosexuality. Then weâll talk.
Hamish retweeted
Replying to @BrookeHodgman @hatfinch
Oh you did finally read it and get embarrassed enough to delete your post. Good work đ
Hamish retweeted
67 minutes.
That's how long it took for "false flag" theories to start flooding social media after flydubai Flight FZ1073 sent its first emergency signal. I've written about conspiracy thinking for decades, and it does not surprise me that they start spreading in the digital age before anyone actually knows what happened. Facts are not necessary for conspiracy theories to go viral.
Over 12 hours, @CombatASemitism researchers tracking X counted nearly 3,000 posts blaming Israel, the Mossad, Netanyahu, "Zionists," or Jews. A thousand of them came within five hours. Among posts using the phrase "false flag," roughly 72% were pushing that, and by the final hours it was above 80%.
After any major catastrophe, expect it. Psychologists call it proportionality bias: a huge event feels like it needs an equally huge cause. A simple explanation is not enough for many people, so they reach for a far more complicated and nefarious hidden hand.
That instinct is human. But that does not explain what happened here in the hours as the story was unfolding. These conspiracies are created and distributed by opportunists, hostile governments, and professional Jew-haters. They want to fill the online vacuum before the facts arrive.
Look at the first day. The false-flag frame was available from state-linked media in Tehran almost immediately. Iran's semiofficial Fars news agency cited unnamed Iranian security agencies claiming Israel was planning an aviation attack to pin on Tehran, and ran that claim alongside the diversion of this flight. Of course, it offered no evidence linking the two.
At the same time, unverified accounts were inventing details about who was involved, leaning on India-Pakistan hostility to assign nationalities to the people on board before authorities had said anything.
I can't tell you the posts on X were coordinated, and I won't pretend to. That takes evidence, the same standard I'd demand of the conspiracy theorists. What the record does show is a script that was ready before the event, and an event that provided the ideal occasion for it.
Look at what that script does. Israelis on a plane someone tried to crash become the suspects. The victims are erased and the blame is flipped in about an hour.
None of this is a game. A huge share of people now get their news from TikTok clips and memes, not from reading. For them a viral lie that arrives first becomes the truth. Distrust any explanation that shows up before the evidence does.
Hamish retweeted
Chers spécialistes du "génocide", qui avez appris le mot le 8 octobre, votre intelligence m'impressionne et me dépasse. Un modeste idiot vous soumet ses questions, soyez indulgents :
- Pourquoi plus de 97% des Gazaouis sont-ils toujours en vie aprÚs trois ans de guerre, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi s'ĂȘtre retirĂ© de Gaza en 2005 si le projet est un gĂ©nocide ?
- Pourquoi fournir l'électricité et une partie de l'eau de Gaza pendant 18 ans, si le projet est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi prÚs de 20 000 Gazaouis avaient-ils un permis de travail en Israël la veille du 7 octobre, si le projet est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi attendre 75 ans, et commencer pile aprÚs le pire massacre de Juifs depuis la Shoah, si le projet est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi le Hamas, dont la charte appelle à tuer les Juifs et qui a mis son programme en pratique en massacrant des familles entiÚres le 7 octobre, n'est-il jamais accusé de génocide, lui ?
- Pourquoi prévenir par SMS et par tracts avant de frapper, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi publier des cartes d'évacuation quartier par quartier, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi envoyer des soldats mourir dans les rues au lieu de tout raser d'en haut, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi le Hamas se cache-t-il sous les civils, alors que les boucliers humains ne marchent que contre une armée qui les épargne, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi vacciner des centaines de milliers d'enfants palestiniens contre la polio, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi faire entrer des dizaines de milliers de camions de nourriture, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi évacuer des milliers de malades vers des hÎpitaux étrangers, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi accepter des cessez-le-feu en échange d'otages, si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi arrĂȘter la guerre le jour oĂč le Hamas rend les otages, si c'est un gĂ©nocide ?
- Pourquoi épargner les 2 millions d'Arabes israéliens d'origine palestinienne (20 % de la population), si c'est un génocide ?
- Pourquoi la guerre est-elle Ă Gaza et pas en Cisjordanie, oĂč vit la majoritĂ© des Palestinien, si c'est un gĂ©nocide ?
- Pourquoi parlait-on dĂ©jĂ de gĂ©nocide avant mĂȘme l'entrĂ©e des troupes Ă Gaza, si c'est un constat et non un slogan ?
Hamish retweeted
Replying to @RachelMoiselle
They rush to add context to violence against Israelis until it can be explained away as deserved, like history cashing a check that was owed.
And they rush to remove context from violence by Israelis until it can be made to look gratuitous and bloodthirsty.
That is the game.
Hamish retweeted
A Scottish newspaper leads with satellite images of Gaza's rubble under the headline "Show this to anyone denying genocide."
What I keep wondering is why more people aren't furious at Hamas, which chose this war on October 7 and, in violation of the Geneva Conventions, chose to fight it from inside Gaza's homes, schools and hospitals.
Modern urban warfare leaves landscapes like this. Aerial photos of Berlin, Warsaw or Tokyo in 1945 looked no different. When one side embeds itself among civilians, it's hard to imagine the war ending any differently.
But the level of destruction doesn't decide whether something is genocide. Neither does the death toll. The legal test is intent: a specific intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group as such.
The picture on that front page can't answer the question it claims to settle.
I laid out the legal test, and why Gaza doesn't meet it, in a plain-language primer: justthefacts.media/p/genocidâŠ
Hamish retweeted
I'm seeing quite a bit of comment about this, so I want to make a couple of points.
I'm not owed eternal agreement from any actor who once played a character I created. The idea is as ludicrous as me checking with the boss I had when I was twenty-one for what opinions I should hold these days.
Emma Watson and her co-stars have every right to embrace gender identity ideology. Such beliefs are legally protected, and I wouldn't want to see any of them threatened with loss of work, or violence, or death, because of them.
However, Emma and Dan in particular have both made it clear over the last few years that they think our former professional association gives them a particular right - nay, obligation - to critique me and my views in public. Years after they finished acting in Potter, they continue to assume the role of de facto spokespeople for the world I created.
When you've known people since they were ten years old it's hard to shake a certain protectiveness. Until quite recently, I hadn't managed to throw off the memory of children who needed to be gently coaxed through their dialogue in a big scary film studio. For the past few years, I've repeatedly declined invitations from journalists to comment on Emma specifically, most notably on the Witch Trials of JK Rowling. Ironically, I told the producers that I didn't want her to be hounded as the result of anything I said.
The television presenter in the attached clip highlights Emma's 'all witches' speech, and in truth, that was a turning point for me, but it had a postscript that hurt far more than the speech itself. Emma asked someone to pass on a handwritten note from her to me, which contained the single sentence 'I'm so sorry for what you're going through' (she has my phone number). This was back when the death, rape and torture threats against me were at their peak, at a time when my personal security measures had had to be tightened considerably and I was constantly worried for my family's safety. Emma had just publicly poured more petrol on the flames, yet thought a one line expression of concern from her would reassure me of her fundamental sympathy and kindness.
Like other people who've never experienced adult life uncushioned by wealth and fame, Emma has so little experience of real life she's ignorant of how ignorant she is. She'll never need a homeless shelter. She's never going to be placed on a mixed sex public hospital ward. I'd be astounded if she's been in a high street changing room since childhood. Her 'public bathroom' is single occupancy and comes with a security man standing guard outside the door. Has she had to strip off in a newly mixed-sex changing room at a council-run swimming pool? Is she ever likely to need a state-run rape crisis centre that refuses to guarantee an all-female service? To find herself sharing a prison cell with a male rapist who's identified into the women's prison?
I wasn't a multimillionaire at fourteen. I lived in poverty while writing the book that made Emma famous. I therefore understand from my own life experience what the trashing of women's rights in which Emma has so enthusiastically participated means to women and girls without her privileges.
The greatest irony here is that, had Emma not decided in her most recent interview to declare that she loves and treasures me - a change of tack I suspect she's adopted because she's noticed full-throated condemnation of me is no longer quite as fashionable as it was - I might never have been this honest.
Adults can't expect to cosy up to an activist movement that regularly calls for a friend's assassination, then assert their right to the former friend's love, as though the friend was in fact their mother. Emma is rightly free to disagree with me and indeed to discuss her feelings about me in public - but I have the same right, and I've finally decided to exercise it.
âI think sheâs going to find that you canât sit on the fence... The real win is when ordinary people can say these things.â
@DerryBanShee speaks to @joshxhowie about Emma Watsonâs comments about JK Rowling.
đș youtu.be/r2OGEITYe2Y
Hamish retweeted
We read that Scottish Ministers have shelved plans to ban âconversion therapyâ. Thank goodness for that. Apparently the Scottish Greens are furious. Of course they are.
No one who has been following these discussions, from the Council of Europe to the UK, supports such a ban. It is a scam.
The revolting practices known as âgay conversion therapyâ are already illegal. They have been for decades. The only âconversion therapyâ that is still going on is the practice of telling a girl she may be a boy trapped in a girlâs body â or vice versa. Or telling children itâs possible to convert their bodies to be the opposite sex. Banning those practices would be great.
Those favouring a ban on what they deceptively call âconversion practicesâ want the opposite. They want all children who say theyâre the opposite sex to be âaffirmedâ in that belief.
Iâm glad Holyrood appears to be stepping back from the brink and I hope Westminster will do the same.
Hamish retweeted
PICARD: Data, shields up
DATA: Brilliant! Shields can reduce damage we sustain. Not immunity. Not hubris. Just prudence. It's not precautionâit's strategy.
[camera shakes]
WORF: HULL BREACHES ON NINE DECKS
DATA: Here's what happened: you told me to raise shields, and I didn't
Hamish retweeted
As another man who once worked with me declares himself saddened by my beliefs on gender and sex, I thought it might be useful to compile a list for handy reference. Which of the following do you imagine makes actors and directors who arenât involved with the HBO reboot of Harry Potter so miserable?
Is it my belief that women and girls should have their own public changing rooms and bathrooms?
That women should retain female-only rape crisis centres?
That men donât belong in womenâs sport?
That female prisoners shouldnât be incarcerated with violent men and male sex offenders?
That women should remain a protected class in law, because they have sex-specific needs and issues?
That language should reflect reality rather than ideological jargon, especially in a medical context?
That women shouldnât be harassed, persecuted or fired for refusing to pretend humans can change sex?
That women should not be threatened with violence and rape when they assert their rights?
That freedom of speech and belief are essential to a pluralistic democratic society?
That troubled minors, especially those who are gay, autistic and trauma-experienced, should be given mental health support instead of irreversible surgeries and drug treatments on non-existent evidence of benefit?
That gay people shouldnât be pressured to include the opposite sex in their dating pools, nor should they be smeared as âgenital fetishistsâ when they donât?
That cross-dressing heterosexual male fetishists arenât actually oppressed, but having the time of their lives piggybacking off gender identity ideology?
That said ideology, and the privileged, blinkered fools pushing it because they suffer zero consequences themselves, have done more damage to the political leftâs credibility than Trump and Farage could have achieved in a century?
Let me have your thoughts.


























