Anton (@p1154) profile picture
Joined June 2009
Photo by Anton (@p1154)Photo by Anton (@p1154)Photo by Anton (@p1154)Photo by Anton (@p1154)Photo by Anton (@p1154)Photo by Anton (@p1154)
Anton retweeted
Replying to @JessBrownFuller
This is disingenuous. No-one, and certainly no "victim" is forced to watch his YouTube channel. His wife is broadcasting, not him. Furthermore Russell Brand has a right to claim innocence if he considers himself to be innocent. Many other prisoners have done the same. There is such a thing as miscarriage of justice. Just because he was convicted does not mean he is necessarily guilty as charged. The jury decided he is guilty, but juries get it wrong sometimes.
9
13
658
12,909
Anton retweeted
Let's not forget that Professor Hindmarsh came up with the unproven sticky insulin theory, which he admitted was based on no research whatsoever, and additionally was well outside his field of expertise. Yes, insulin does stick to IV bags and tubing which practitioners need to be aware of, but scientifically it can be shown that it doesn't unstick in the presence of a dextrose solution - a fact that as a paediatric endocrinologist Hindmarsh would not have known. His testimony on this should be thrown out. Yet the prosecution relied on this in order to show how Letby could have been responsible for Baby L's insulin poisoning for the period of a day and a half, when she was off-duty and new "uncontaminated" dextrose bags were hung. But Hindmarsh even admitted in cross-examination that his hypoglycaemia calculations would have required more insulin added to the new bags over this period (that Letby wasn't there), something the prosecution made no attempt to explain. I've also pointed out that the giving set was undoubtedly changed with the next bag change after Letby went off-duty, so the theory is completely irrelevant anyway. For a longer read on this ⬇️ nitter.gq/JabesAllowed/status/20…
1/3 Baby L And The Flawed Case of Alleged Insulin Poisoning Following on from my previous post, here I will debunk the "sticky insulin" theory proposed by Professor Hindmarsh, which was endorsed by Nick Johnson KC as the sole explanation for Baby L’s persistent hypoglycaemia after Lucy Letby had gone off shift. I will also argue that this undermines the allegation of insulin poisoning at any point in the case of Baby L. See the attached chart for a visual representation of Baby L’s blood glucose readings over the relevant period, set against the timing of dextrose bag changes and other key events. The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby injected insulin into multiple bags of dextrose solution on 9th April, resulting in a 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode. But there was a major problem with this allegation. The hypoglycaemic episode, which Professor Hindmarsh attributed to exogenous insulin, continued for nearly two days after Lucy Letby had gone off duty. During that period, two new dextrose bags were hung which she could not have poisoned. The only insulin blood test done was on 9th April. How, then, could the prosecution attribute the continuing hypoglycaemia to alleged insulin poisoning by Lucy Letby? Nick Johnson KC relied on Professor Hindmarsh’s sticky insulin theory. According to Hindmarsh, insulin from a spiked dextrose bag, which had stuck to the plastic inner surface of the giving set, could later be released into the dextrose infusion after a new, uncontaminated bag was connected. (A giving set is the sterile tubing that connects an infusion bag to a cannula or long line; trial testimony indicated that it isn't necessarily changed when a dextrose bag is replaced.) No calculations — in fact, no figures of any kind — were provided to support this suggested mechanism. Aside from the obvious flaws in the theory itself, it also depended on the giving set not being changed through two bag changes - something that was never established. Here, I will show that not only is the sticky insulin theory scientifically invalid, it’s also inapplicable, because the giving set definitely was changed when a new dextrose bag was hung after Lucy Letby had gone home. Firstly, a quick run-through of the key events: 9th April 2016 (See chart for the timings of the dextrose bags and blood glucose readings.) Lucy Letby was accused of spiking 3 bags with insulin on 9th April, though she was not Baby L’s designated nurse; there was no evidence that she actually did so. Baby L (and his twin Baby M) had been born on the morning of the previous day, 8th April, and he was receiving dextrose to bring his blood glucose levels up. By midnight, a normal reading of 3.6 was recorded. The allegation was that Lucy Letby spiked this dextrose bag the next day, 9th April, at some point between starting shift at 7.30am and 9.30am. This would have been while it was hanging, which is implausible in itself, especially as Letby wasn't his designated nurse on that day. This was Bag #1. At 10am Baby L’s blood glucose reading was low at 1.9, and this is where the 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode identified by Professor Hindmarsh began. Bag #1 was replaced at midday on 9th April, after having been in use for the standard 24 hours. The replacement bag was hung by Lucy Letby and Mary Griffith, Baby L's designated nurse. This was Bag #2. The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby also poisoned this bag, though no explanation was given as to how or when. At some point before 3.45pm (the exact timing was uncertain), a blood sample was taken and sent to Liverpool for insulin testing. Several days later, the results came back showing a high insulin level alongside low C-peptide — findings associated with the presence of exogenous insulin. This formed the basis of the allegation that Lucy Letby had poisoned Baby L with artificial insulin. At 4.30pm that same day, the dextrose bag was changed again, this time to a more concentrated 12.5% dextrose solution. This bag was hung by Belinda Williamson (Simcock) and Ashleigh Hudson. This was Bag #3. The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby also poisoned this bag with insulin after it had been hung, though again no explanation was provided as to how or when. Throughout this period, Baby L continued to record abnormally low blood glucose readings. Lucy Letby finished her shift on 9th April at 8pm, remaining for another hour or so to complete her nursing notes. This was her fourth consecutive day of work following which she was then off duty for several days. 10th – 11th April 2016 In the early hours of 10th April, at around 2.30am, the dextrose bag was changed again, this time to a 15% dextrose solution. This was Bag #4. The prosecution did not allege that Lucy Letby poisoned this bag as she had already been off shift for several hours by then. Nevertheless, low blood glucose levels continued at roughly the same level throughout the night and into the following morning. From this point onwards the only explanation given for the continuing hypoglycaemia was the sticky insulin theory: that insulin from the previous bag, Bag #3, had stuck to the inner surface of the giving set and was now being released into the infusion. There was a further bag – Bag #5 – hung up 24 hours later on 11th April; the low blood glucose readings persisted but later in the day spontaneously returned to a normal level. To summarise: 1.We have a 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode, identified by Professor Hindmarsh, running from 10am on 9th April 2016 until 3pm on 11th April. 2.Professor Hindmarsh had no explanation for this episode other than the presence of exogenous insulin throughout the entire period. 3.Lucy Letby was only on shift during the first day, 9th April, until 8pm. 4.On 9th April there were three different dextrose bags in use, all of which the prosecution alleged Lucy Letby had poisoned. 5.Two further bags were hung in the early hours of 10th and 11th April, producing no marked change in glucose levels until the afternoon of 11th April. 6.Since Lucy Letby could not physically have poisoned those last two bags, Professor Hindmarsh relied on the sticky insulin theory to explain the continuing hypoglycaemia. Evidence that the giving Set WAS changed If it could be proven that the giving set was changed with Bag #4 then that would nullify the sticky insulin theory, wouldn't it? Well, it can be proven, because prior to Bag #4 being hung there was a long line put in by Dr A specifically to be used with the next dextrose bag. And when a long line is connected up a new, sterile giving set is always used to prevent infection! This is well known and there's no doubt about it. There was even trial testimony confirming this practice from two nurses, in relation to the stock bag used for Baby F. Dr Sandie Bohin also confirmed it. Dr A’s reason for inserting the long line was that he was intending to increase the dextrose concentration to 15%, which is above the maximum level of 12.5% which can be infused through a catheter, which is what had been used up to then. The long line was put in at around 1am on 10th April, and following this Bag #4 was hung at 2.30am. (See chart – the timing of the long line insertion is shown as blue line.) Therefore, the sticky insulin theory — that "stuck" insulin was being released from the giving set after Bag #4 was hung — cannot possibly account for the continuation of hypoglycaemia after this bag-change event, because the giving set previously used was no longer in place! The prosecution’s case that this mechanism explained the continuing hypoglycaemia is completely invalid. References: Dr A’s medical notes from that night which refer to the long line can be seen here at page 2 (he was cyphered as Dr U at Thirlwall): thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk/… The long line insertion was also brought up in his Thirlwall Inquiry oral testimony (see pages 223–226): thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk/… And it was also reported by the Chester Standard’s live trial reporting at the time (see entry at 12.13pm): chesterstandard.co.uk/news/2…
2
48
5
106
3,894
The conviction of Lucy Letby hangs on four experts. It is, by now, blindingly obvious that Dewi Evans, Sandie Bohin, and Peter Hindmarsh should never have been involved. And Andreas Marnerides didn't read any of the medical records, essentially parroting the opinion of Evans (bit embarrassing for him now). In fact, Marnerides didn't even inform the prosecution barristers that he hadn't read the notes, as is obvious if you read the court transcript of 29 March 2023. Even Nick Johnson is surprised! I have read every word that this quartet said in court. Some of their testimony is literally laughable. In the case of Evans and Bohin, they have, firstly, informed the court that every infant was well and stable. You can learn more about this here: youtube.com/watch?v=1dsU42y_… youtube.com/watch?v=soErXpOP… They then almost entirely failed to inform the court that there was a litany of egregious medical errors made. In fact, this unit, described by Dr Shoo Lee as one that would be closed in Canada, was effusively praised by Evans throughout the court case, as you can see here: youtube.com/watch?v=74xJG_zg… Indeed, the overall impression conveyed by Evans and Bohin is scientifically, medically and evidentially indefensible. The Lucy Letby case is an utter debacle. It would be woeful under any circumstances, but this is supposed to be one of the most important criminal cases of this century. It is instead an enormous national embarrassment. The court system must facilitate the hearing of credible medical evidence in a court of law, and indeed expedite this. And I mean in the Crown Court, not the Court of Appeal. The bare minimum requirement for this case is a retrial. #LucyLetby #LucyLetbyInnocent theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
25
92
12
244
6,102
Anton retweeted
Replying to @LucyLetbyTrials
Looks like someone at GOSH, UCLH or even the GMC has joined in with the leaking. Well done that person👍
2
26
590
Replying to @LucyLetbyTrials
The Guardian has previously reported on the disciplinary procedures against Hindmarsh, so for those who, like me, wondered what is the new information in this article, this is it:
1
18
598
"Doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial." "Among the reasons for UCLH's decision was that his advice to child patients relating to insulin was not considered safe." "Jury was never told" theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
32
155
20
397
35,840
Replying to @BenObeseJecty
How is Brand’s Christian message "grotesque"? How does Russell’s right to maintain he is innocent show a "willingness" to "cause ongoing harm and distress" to accusers? This is a maliciously constructed false narrative!
9
15
324
2,771
Anton retweeted
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon. Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably? Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit? I am genuinely curious about these questions.
5,148
11,812
1,073
112,880
5,390,009
THE CROWN vs RUSSELL EDWARD BRAND ➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖⚖️ Evidence and Witnesses. The commentary on witnesses and evidence in the Russell Brand case is all over the show. A few things urgently need clearing up. WITNESSES. Brand and Complainant 5 were alone together at his home, in his bedroom. Nobody else was in that bedroom the entire time she was there. So there are no witnesses. Full stop. And because there can be no witnesses, that is precisely what makes it a he-said / she-said case. Unlike a true creep and predator, Brand did not have cameras set up secretly recording their rendezvous. Which is actually quite ironic. Recording the encounter is almost something you could guarantee a real predator and sick monster would do. The fact he did not record it, is a strong argument that he treated her with ordinary respect and decency, not as prey. EVIDENCE As for what constitutes “evidence” This is where I see the most confusion in the discourse. And this is why it is imperative to understand the specifics of this case. People are arguing about forensic evidence and the lack thereof, as though it is somehow important here. Those discussions only expose the commentator as having no clue about this specific matter. I am genuinely bloody gobsmacked at how few people have taken five minutes to learn the basic established facts. Forensic evidence is not important here because Brand has never denied he had sexual relations with Complainant 5. THE MOST IMPORTANT THING TO KNOW Russell Brand is serving a nine-year prison term for a rape conviction because he cannot prove he had consent. So when it comes to the topic of evidence, the ONLY evidence that matters here is PROOF OF CONSENT. And herein lies the problem that affects everyone: what “proof” will satisfy the law that two adults both consented to sex? Brand is behind bars tonight because he cannot prove consent. So the question becomes: what constitutes consent in the eyes of the law? What does it look like? Do we need a written contract agreeing to sex from now on? Do we need to record a video clearly stating we give content? Or in this case, to be fair — what could Russell have produced in court to satisfy the claim that he did have consent? The answer is nothing. There is nothing he could have produced to prove he had consent, despite everything that led to Complainant 5 arriving at his home being the normal motions any of us would go through to have consensual sex with a partner. And that’s the injustice. The judge gave no indication or direction — as he handed down the sentence putting Brand in prison and praised all the stunning and brave groupies for coming forward 20 years later — as to what in God’s name he would accept as proof of consent. All other discourse about witnesses and evidence is pointless, and it misses the mark as to the very concerning precedent this sets for everyone else in the realms of the Commonwealth.
142
200
21
833
70,072
This @gladwell fraud (never heard of him) looks like the telemarketers from the 1990s who would sell get rich fast schemes on late night TV infomercials. Someone should alert Dr. Puskas that he is not being represented very well…
Going to think twice before reading more of his books @Gladwell
4
3
1
46
7,846
Damn, I’ve doing it wrong all these years.
Going to think twice before reading more of his books @Gladwell
13
2
1
75
7,627
Russell Brand’s ex-girlfriend Samantha Pressdee has fiercely spoken out against the verdict. She stated the following: "A wife is without her husband. Three children are without their Dad. Yet everyone thinks the real victim in this is a drunk groupie who was cheating on her boyfriend. Someone who has anonymity for life and will probably get a financial payout. “If this drunk groupie thought he was a predator, why would she stand by and watch him sleep with 1000s more women? Didn't she care about those women? "It's not true that women in the comedy industry warned each other about Russell. No one warned me, and it could not have been more obvious that I was connected to him. Just because I am a woman doesn't mean I should 'believe all women'. "I would be more likely to believe women who report criminals to the POLICE. Not the media, decades later. I believe in the right to a fair trial. Convince me it was fair!" She also slammed Georgina Bailey who claimed to be Brand’s ex-lover and had urged him to “tell the truth.” "She was a groupie too,” Samantha revealed. “The kind of women throwing themselves at Brand back then often sold kiss-and-tell [stories] that were mostly made up. "Russell paid for Georgina to go to rehab. Ballie has made a career out of sleeping with him. She's not his ex-girlfriend. At the time, she was in a burlesque troupe called 'The Satanic Sluts'." At the moment, we are being led to believe that Russell Brand is guilty beyond reasonable doubt. There is no evidence - only the word of one woman and more words from people who don’t like him. Now we have other words from someone who knew him that say the opposite of what the establishment and media are saying. I also found Reform MP Sarah Pochin’s comments on TalkTV disgraceful. In the clip, she spoke about Brand as if he was 100% guilty, spoke in a rather venomous way about him saying she hoped he would go away for a long long time, and spoke about the accusers as if they are bastions of truth even though there is no way she could possibly know that. This is trial by media. Trial by hearsay. Trial by dislike of one person. But trial by truth? No. Russell Brand faces serious danger in prison and was forbidden from saying goodbye to his kids. No mercy is being shown to him. I see only venom and hate. Yet I have seen Brand speak repeatedly about his faith for years, urging millions of people to find their own. The entire thing feels off and rancid. The more this case goes on and the more that is revealed by people like his ex-girlfriend, the more it becomes clear that something very wrong has happened here and we are in the midst of watching something very evil taking place. #RussellBrand Russell Brand’s ex-girlfriend Samantha Pressdee has fiercely spoken out against the verdict. She stated the following: "... ift.tt/HreIXgz
692
3,583
221
20,458
2,898,377
NEW: California attorney Julie Hamill corrects CNN's Brianna Keilar after she tried calling biological male track athlete AB Hernandez a girl. Keilar was very confused during the interview & struggled to keep up. Keilar: What would make this fair for her to compete? Hamill: Who is her? Keilar: AB. Hamill: Okay. AB Hernandez is a male who identifies as a female. What would be fair is to have Hernandez competing in the male category. @hamill_law sounds like she's talking to someone in middle school.
720
2,500
149
13,180
364,529
Replying to @MartynPitman
They do not mention Thirlwall's extraordinary recommendation *not* to encourage the use of expensive LC-MS/MS to investigate possible insulin poisoning because doctors would only be confused if it gave different outcomes from quick and cheap immunoassay!
5
14
1
44
472
Replying to @rbarbosa91
The Saturday Grand Rounds allowed surgeons from the community to attend…I see no evidence that weekday Grand Rounds produce better surgeons.
2
1
14
5,487
He asks me about PT. In the notes He asks about MRI. In the notes He asks then why would I want an epidural injection I don’t… I want an SI injection “Oh it was coded wrong then…you’ll have to resubmit. Nothing I can do” It’s not a bug, it’s a feature. Insurance is fraud
7
15
887
18,690
Has America had a rapid and sudden rise in deaths due to malnutrition? This has become a common anti-American talking point, but is it true? Well, that is what the death certificates say, but that's just because we started writing them differently!
8
17
3
243
42,898
Pay hospitals more if “malnutrition” is in the chart. Hospitals hire teams to comb through patient charts and harass doctors into putting “malnutrition” in the clinical notes. More people are suddenly dying with “malnutrition” as a diagnosis. This is why most research based on administrative codes is total garbage.
Has America had a rapid and sudden rise in deaths due to malnutrition? This has become a common anti-American talking point, but is it true? Well, that is what the death certificates say, but that's just because we started writing them differently!
21
55
3
494
21,516
A husband and wife with four kids will spend $3-4,000 and more per month on medical insurance now, and it buys nothing but the right to pay more when you actually use it. This is an outrage. More outrageous, there is hardly any political talk about this fixing this problem even though the fix is readily at hand. Unsustainable.
345
749
63
4,600
116,113