karl me maybe (@soothlayer) header
karl me maybe (@soothlayer) profile picture

post-national materialist

Joined May 2019
Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)
communism is NOT "when communists are in power"
26
38
5
654
20,170
"China directly or indirectly makes about 3.5% of the goods Americans buy." The Dangerous Illusion of the 3.5% Why a low statistic hides a massive strategic vulnerability. At first glance, the claim that "China directly or indirectly makes only about 3.5% of the goods Americans buy" feels reassuring. It suggests that despite the geopolitical noise, the two economies are relatively distinct and that US reliance on Chinese manufacturing is manageable—a minor feature of a vast economy rather than a structural pillar. However, relying on this figure to measure dependency is a dangerous mistake. It confuses economic value with strategic criticality. By focusing on the final price tag of goods, US leaders mask two profound vulnerabilities: an addiction to artificially cheap consumption and a fragility in US critical supply chains that no GDP statistic can capture. The "Welfare" Trap of Cheap Consumption The primary reason the 3.5% figure is so low is that Chinese manufacturing is incredibly efficient and inexpensive. When an American buys a toaster or a smartphone, the vast majority of that purchase price stays in the US to pay for branding, logistics, retail real estate, and marketing. Only a sliver flows back to the factory in Shenzhen. Economically, this looks like low dependence. In reality, it is a form of consumer welfare. Because Chinese production effectively subsidizes the cost of living for the American working and middle classes, it provides a "standard of living surplus" that allows Americans to buy more with less. The US has effectively outsourced the suppression of inflation. To "liberate" the US economy from this dynamic would not just mean shifting factories; it would mean accepting a sudden, sharp decrease in purchasing power. The reliance isn't measured in dollars spent, but in the lifestyle those dollars can afford. The US is not just buying goods; it is importing a subsidy that holds its consumer economy together. The 0.000001% That Matters The second, and more lethal, flaw in the "it’s not a lot" argument is the assumption that all dollars are created equal. They are not. In a complex system, a $10 billion import of plastic toys counts the same as a $10 billion import of advanced pharmaceuticals or rare earth magnets. But if the toys stop arriving, Americans are merely annoyed. If the magnets stop arriving, industries collapse. This is the Rare Earth Paradox. The strategic minerals required to build F-35 fighter jets, EV batteries, and medical MRI machines represent a microscopic fraction of the US GDP—perhaps 0.000001%. Yet, they are the indispensable "vitamins" of the industrial body. A human body can survive without thousands of calories of starch, but it will shut down without a tiny amount of iron or B12. China’s dominance in the processing of these elements means they hold the keys to the entire high-tech ecosystem. The low dollar value of these imports is actually what makes them so dangerous: because they were cheap, the US ignored them. Because they represented a rounding error on the balance sheet, the US allowed a geopolitical rival to monopolize the choke points of the future. Further, ​this "only 3.5% claim" underscores the fragile symbiosis between the two nations. While the US economy retains the high-value service functions—branding, logistics, retail real estate, and marketing—these sectors are entirely contingent upon the continuous, low-cost flow of Chinese manufactured goods. If this supply stops, billions in US logistics capital and millions of related jobs are instantly rendered obsolete, triggering a massive, domestic economic contraction.
China directly or indirectly makes about 3.5% of the goods Americans buy. That's not nothing, but it's...not a lot.
21
82
9
404
51,869
karl me maybe retweeted
The totality of these relations of production constitutes the economic structure of society, the real foundation, on which arises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite forms of social consciousness.
2
35
2
155
7,107
China wants to be seen as the champion of the Global South, waves the anti-imperialist flag at every BRICS photo-op, and lectures the West about Palestine… yet quietly keeps the economic and tech pipeline to Israel wide open because it’s profitable.
This quoted post is unavailable.
7
66
4
246
8,486
Replying to @soothlayer
The struggle between China & US is a struggle for more share of the surplus value extracted. That's why we can see after every period of political crisis there will be readjustment. Multipolarity bros think this contradiction is socialism. XD
2
5
28
1,038
Vile chauvinism is the putrid rot left by the corpse of Stalinism. “Socialism in one country” has always meant putting the narrow national interests of a conservative ruling stratum above the interests of the international proletariat, at home and abroad
China doesn't owe shit to anyone but the Chinese people. Just like the rest of the world doesn't owe shit to China.
9
24
6
164
8,331
How can you seriously ask the masses to join a “socialist” movement when you can’t even define what you’re fighting for?
1
1
1
33
1,771
Replying to @soothlayer
China supplies advanced weapons to UAE that send them to the RSF in Sudan to commit genocide with, all so UAE can keep stealing Sudanese gold to sell to China. Meanwhile China also supplies weapons to the SAF to keep the conflict going, because that way they can sell more weapons to UAE. Yeah, but, "China doesn't interfere".
2
30
2
87
3,034
There will be communism & it will be global. ✊️
how do you even live with the knowledge that we lost and that it is too late to achieve communism
22
11
2
137
8,470
It's never been more clear to me the Lacanian-Hegelians, I'm sorry to say, have no idea what Marx is talking about. They've either never read beyond the first few chs of Vol. I, or have & are willingly & opportunistically producing terrible readings. Same for Lacanian "Marxists."
12
4
6
145
17,897
Everything stated here is correct.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
2
5
1
40
2,548
Marxism has always critiqued how feminism fails to eradicate patriarchy by positioning gender as the primary contradiction, instead of class which is what created sex oppression in the first place. By failing to eradicate the source, it fails to eradicate the symptom. HOWEVER,
46
483
149
7,056
291,971
“…for Marx there are no social facts in themselves which can be apprehended through traditional disciplinary boundaries. The real ‘object of knowledge’ is the social phenomenon as a whole, hence capital as totality. But this latter must be understood not as if the empirically given conditions of production are the immediate object of knowledge. Rather, Marx proceeds through a criticism of bourgeois categories and theories. [33]Theory and its ‘objective’ content are related, but they are not one and the same. That’s why the method of inquiry is formally different from the method of presentation. The method of inquiry, Schmidt explains, deals with material from history, economics, sociology, statistics and so on, and through the ‘isolating’ and ‘analysing’ of understanding. The method of presentation, in contrast, has to bring concrete unity to these isolated data. ‘Exhibition’, following Hegel, proceeds from immediate ‘being’ to mediating ‘essence’, which is the ground of being. Essential reality must manifest itself phenomenally, but this concrete instantiation of essence is distinguished from its manifestation. Although even the most abstract categories have a historical determinate dimension, the logical course is different from, and even opposite to, the historical course. These issues are further developed by Schmidt in his History and Structure: For Hegel, as well as Marx, reality is a process: ‘negative’ totality. In Hegelianism, this process appears as a system of reason. That is as a closed ontology, from which human history sinks to the level of being its derivative, a mere instance of its application. By contrast, Marx emphasises the independence and the openness of historical development, which cannot be reduced to a speculative logic that all beings must forever obey. Hence ‘negativity’ comes to refer to something which is limited in time, while ‘totality’ implies the whole of the modern relations of production. [34] There is a gnoseological primacy of the logical moment over the historical: without a prior theoretical understanding of capital one would not know where to look for the historical presupposition of its birth. [35] But this does not make categories the existential ground of reality, as for Hegel. Rather, categories mediate reality in knowledge. However, this critique of Hegel does not cancel Marx’s debt to the Hegelian notion of ‘system’. The concrete is not what stands in front of human intellect, but a ‘unity of the manifold’, knowledge which, even though it has as its necessary basis in the analytical method, dialectically evades the dichotomy of the factual and the mental. Thus, Marx proceeds logically, and not historically, because the form of capital that he developed posits its own conditions of existence.” - Bellofiore & Riva, The Neue Marx-Lektüre
2
10
1
33
2,562
The ruling class is panicking because Millennials and Gen Z own nothing, have nothing to lose, and no reason to defend capitalism. The promises have collapsed & the spell is broken. No amount of Cold War rhetoric & nostalgia on social media can reverse it 🔥🤝🔥🤝🔥
235
1,931
70
9,276
114,350
Replying to @jbarro
Too much buccal removal: lib Too much lip filler: maga
14
74
11
7,182
383,838
Maoism is a stillborn critique of stalinism which partially recognizes the problems that come with fusing party and state, but generally keeps the party-state model anyway, and tries to rectify these problems with political voluntarism.
6
4
1
83
2,389
bringing back this banger. "class reductionism" is not the problem on the left, if anything we are LACKING in class analysis.
class reductionism is not a real thing to any significant degree. I only ever see it as a strawman by anti-marxists like Liberal Turtle here.
4
8
78
1,700