karl me maybe (@soothlayer) header
karl me maybe (@soothlayer) profile picture

post-national materialist

Joined May 2019
Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)Photo by karl me maybe (@soothlayer)
As things get worse and worse and worse, our revolutionary optimism should grow. It's when the people relent to despair that communists come in and revitalize them with revolutionary fury and optimism. That's your whole mission as a communist.
1
5
1
36
4,912
Replying to @PolPot114514_
China’s caution isn’t socialist; it’s developmentalist. Every capitalist state in history has said "we must finish national construction first." It’s a bourgeois argument, not Marxism
1
1
109
Oh no you follow me??? LOOL
233
These MLs descended into the most pitiful kind of liberal campist cope when I pointed out Madeline Pendleton was one of theirs xD
1
48
2,567
AES is ONLY an ML position. No other Marxist believes in AES. Madeline is an explicit anti-imperialist and there is no such thing as a "liberal world-systems theory." She supports what she considers periphery states against core imperialism. You're just making up nonsense.
43
Replying to @tovarischrex
I don't keep anyone from calling themselves what they want. I explain why they aren't what they say they are. You have yet to actually explain why the positions she holds are inconsistent with the positions most MLs hold, such as AES, anti-imperialism, world-systems theory, etc.
1
43
Replying to @tovarischrex
You can't even materially define scientific socialism. You're the exact same kind of confused Hegelian she is.
49
different organizing principles of production. If you can’t define the socialist MOP without using Hegelian abstractions like "socialised" or "collectivised," then you’re a Hegelian same as her
36
Replying to @tovarischrex
Socialised/collectivised MOP’ is not a materialist definition of a mode of production. That’s just a moral description of what you want it to be. A material distinction requires: different property relations, different relations of labor, different forms of surplus extraction,
1
41
Replying to @tovarischrex
Bad faith? You apply an arbitrary purity test bc you hate the idea some bourgeois mouthpiece could be associated with your tendency, but everything you've written is just a cope.
1
66
Replying to @tovarischrex
You don't even know the difference between the capitalist and socialist modes of production. You're a Hegelian. Same as her.
1
47
– national sovereignty politics That’s the core of modern ML praxis. Ironically you're being campist yourself.
1
56
Replying to @tovarischrex
You’re not giving a material argument, you’re just listing which sub-sect of ML dogma you personally prefer. Madeline supports: – AES – China as socialist – campist "anti-imperialism" – world-systems rhetoric – party-led development – state-led industrialization
1
66
Replying to @tovarischrex
I’m not going by what any group calls itself. I’m going by the material positions they defend. If supporting state capitalism disqualifies someone from being an ML, then Stalin wasn’t an ML either 🙃
1
53
Replying to @tovarischrex
I don't keep anyone from calling themselves what they want. I explain why they aren't what they say they are. You have yet to actually explain why the positions she holds are inconsistent with the positions most MLs hold, such as AES, anti-imperialism, world-systems theory, etc.
1
1
113
Replying to @tovarischrex
ok gatekeeper of MLs
1
64
Replying to @soothlayer @ymrehh
• DPRK: explicit nationalist ideology (Juche). • Vietnam/Cuba: national development, national accumulation, national industry.
2
71
Replying to @ymrehh
It’s literally the empirical record of every ML state: • USSR: national developmentalism, national security doctrine, nationalized capital accumulation. • PRC: national capital, national bourgeoisie, national markets, national industrial policy.
1
4
81
Replying to @soothlayer @ymrehh
national capital. Material reality > ideological self-description
1
4
64
Replying to @ymrehh
This is like when fascists say they’re "anti-capitalist." Sure, ideologically. In praxis they strengthen capitalism. Same with MLs: you can say "proletarian internationalism," but the historical praxis of every ML state has been nationalism, state-building, and defending
1
3
72
What is scientific socialism materialy?
32