Strange Slate retweeted
“Many are the wanderings and circlings of the soul: one among imaginings, one in opinions and one before these in understanding. But only the life according to νοῦς has stability and this is the mystical harbor of the soul to which, on the one hand, the poem leads Odysseus through the great wandering of his life, and to which we too shall draw ourselves up, if we would reach salvation.” (Proclus, In Parm. Comm. 1025a.29–37)
Strange Slate retweeted
"The bravest are surely those who have the clearest vision of what is before them, glory and danger alike, and yet notwithstanding, go out to meet it."
— Thucydides
Strange Slate retweeted
The last three books of Augustine's _City of God_ Part 2, bks VIII-X, are a wrestling match with Platonism (what we would call 'neo-Platonism', especially Plotinus & Porphyry).
It's worth carefully attending to because of how Augustine frames Christianity as a fulfillment, completion, & correction of Platonism.
"If Plato says that the wise man is the man who imitates, knows & loves this God ['the one true God of supreme goodness'], & that participation in this God brings man happiness, what need is there to examine the other philosophers?
There are none who come nearer to us than the Platonists." (civ. Dei VIII.5)
Here's how Augustine sums up Platonism's progress toward the ultimate truth:
"Thus there are philosophers who have conceived of God, the supreme & true God, as the author of all created things, the light of knowledge, the Final Good of all activity, & who have recognized him as being for us the origin of existence, the truth of doctrine, & the blessedness of life." (civ. Dei VIII.9)
Augustine says that Platonists identified a single, transcendent source of goodness, & affirmed the moral imperative to try to ascend toward it, but that the Platonist's hierarchy offers no real means of reaching the Godhead... sacrificing to false gods, 'demons' (as Augustine argues in Ch. IX) doesn't work. Christ is the Mediator, the being who is both God & man & who alone can help mortals ascend toward pure goodness.
This is a different kind of argument than the historical chronology that Augustine glosses in Part 4, where the earthly & godly cities are intertwined but distinct & fundamentally opposed.
Instead, Christianity is figured as fulfillment & completion of 'Platonism'... Nietzsche called Christianity "Platonism for the people" in the preface to _Beyond Good & Evil_.
But this may also depend on certain facts of Augustine's biography & his own conversion story, as he tried out many philosophies before coming to Christ.
In _Confessions_ VII, Augustine says that the books of the Platonists contained the substance of John 1:1-5 "In the beginning was the Word", but lacked John 1:14 "the Word was made flesh." Whether this reflects his own thinking at the time of his conversion or is a narrative shape from the history of philosophy retroactively-projected onto his autobiography is a question for a more subtle scholar.
& indeed, rather than the sort of rational-spiritual-progress-as-autobiography that Augustine wrote & Newman replicated much later, perhaps 'Christianity as the completion of neo-Platonism' most accurately describes the intellectual milieu in 380s Milan when Augustine converted: a group of Christian or christianizing Latins reading the Enneads in translation, namely Ambrose, Simplicianus, Manlius Theodorus... ultimately inspired by Marius Victorinus, an African rhetor who translated Plotinus into Latin & then converted to Christianity.
In other words, Augustine's idea that Christianity fulfills, completes, & corrects neo-Platonism isn't just cynical apologetics, but also memoir & intellectual sociology.
Strange Slate retweeted
You can go and meet the Eristic Courtiers, if you're keen to ask what they have planned for this uninvited portion of history; or what they don't have planned; or what they plan not to do. There is a renegade camp in the woods beyond the Glassgarden, and here are the Directions:
Strange Slate retweeted
«El argumento decisivo contra la democracia es que lo superior no puede venir de lo que es menos: el pueblo no puede conferir un poder que no posee; el verdadero poder sólo puede emanar de lo alto, de algo superior al orden social, de una autoridad espiritual».
René Guénon
Strange Slate retweeted
Something great and noble in Aristotle is that there is no iron distinction made between so-called ‘virtues of the soul’ and so-called ‘virtues of the body.’ The former might be said to consist of things like temperance, practical wisdom (phronesis), and justice, whereas the latter might be said to consist of things like beauty, cunning (deinotes), and strength.
Aristotle is an ethical hylomorphist. Moral excellence is neither reducible nor indifferent to physiological excellence but instead coextensive with it. Habit is mixed with native potential to actualize excellence of soul and body together.
This (immanent) ethical picture is interrupted St. Thomas Aquinas, who contributes “supernatural virtues” (faith, hope, and charity) equally accessible to the naturally infirm as to the naturally magnificent. Still, importance is kept to natural goods in Aquinas’s formulation: “Gratia non tollit naturam, sed perficit.”
Aristotle is something like a corrective to Nietzsche in that he thinks that there are sure moral virtues, good of themselves and the flourishing they entail, but attainable only by those natural means which differ among men. Some men are, by birth alone, greater than other men and consequently have a greater capacity for virtue. It is also a greater tragedy when the naturally great man slips into vice, as more is lost.
The great man is great for his talent and great for his virtue, but these two greatnesses are only greater together, and Aristotle, indeed, joins them together in the great-souled man, the megalopsychos.
With umbrage to Kant’s bloodlessly universal “kingdom of ends,” Nietzsche appraises moral virtues and ends the pitiable refuse of natural ‘means,’ the epiphenomenon of breeding and physiology (marking the triumph of the will over the good in Kant’s “good will”).
It is out of Kant’s skeptical morality (of the good will) that virtues are purged from their natural basis, and, it is against this diremption that Nietzsche, in defense of ‘life’ and nature, inaugurates his rebellion against ‘morals’ simpliciter.
Strange Slate retweeted
To move forward in time is to unfold the end that is implied in the beginning
Strange Slate retweeted
«Odiamos la democracia con todas nuestras fuerzas. Es el símbolo de todo lo vil, cobarde y corrupto que hay en el mundo».
Ernst Jünger
Strange Slate retweeted
Herein Pageau hints that the association of Ishmael and slavery in the Bible and Christian tradition has explanatory value for the later Islamicate slavetrade. Very interesting suggestion. Goes to show that the universal history tradition's grafting of the peoples of the earth onto figures of biblical genealogy is not arbitrary and often has an intelligible relationship with what those peoples were actually like; it makes sense then, for instance, that the Hungarians associated themselves with Nimrod as their ancestor, who is called “a mighty hunter before the Lord”, the Hungarians originally being a nomadic steppe people who were led to the Carpathian Basin by following the White Stag.
Strange Slate retweeted
Les Fleurs du mal, by Charles Baudelaire, illustrated by Carlos Schwabe, 1900
Strange Slate retweeted
in the pythagorean symbola (σύμβολα), “do not eat your heart” (καρδίην μὴ ἐσθίειν) was interpreted as a warning against consuming the soul through sorrow.
Strange Slate retweeted
The sons of Reuben/Gad/Manasseh built a copy altar, not for sacrifice but remembrance in a foreign land, an act that pleased the Lord & church. This incident can justify art that stirs the mind to remember divinity, without itself being revered as sacred.
Strange Slate retweeted
"Poetry rescues things by reconciling matter with spirit in the metaphor."
— Nicolás Gómez Dávila







































