Tim Minto retweeted
Glass half empty Pessimism is considered morally disgraceful and a sign of a lack of goodwill.
Does expressing pessimism signal a lack of moral virtue? Across eight preregistered studies (N = 3952), forecasters who made pessimistic predictions about the state of the world in the future were consistently judged as morally inferior to forecasters who made optimistic predictions. This moral penalty persisted even when pessimism was evidently accurate, and even pessimists themselves penalized pessimism.
Pessimists appeared less desirous of positive outcomes—a perception that undermined impressions of their morality. Supporting this mechanism, the same pattern emerged when pessimism was merely held in forecasters' private thoughts.
Why is forecasting moralized? Studies 5–6 uncovered that pessimism is seen as a moral failing because it signals uncharitable desires: Pessimists appear to lack goodwill, which reflects poor morals. People judged pessimists as less generous, less sociable, and less likely to engage in moral behaviors (e.g., help someone cross the street).
The finding that pessimism is morally penalized has implications for societal trust in expert predictions. Experts expressing pessimistic forecasts might be publicly dismissed because their outlooks appear uncharitable. [This] could distort collective risk assessments by suppressing necessary caution in critical societal decisions.
Tim Minto retweeted
What is life like at different levels of GDP per capita?
In this new chart I visualised it for 12 different dimensions.
Tim Minto retweeted
Look, if you can't laugh at the president desperately promising angry farmers that he'll magically replace massive quantities of fertilizer from our nextdoor military ally with small imaginary quantities from a tinpot authoritarian thousands of miles away, then you simply have no sense of humor.
Tim Minto retweeted
I think at this point, the right thing for the world to do is to start the process of disconnecting from the USA. It sucks, and it is a long process - but until/unless US congress acts to reduce executive power, it's not obvious that this is just a 4 year long problem.
Tim Minto retweeted
THE GEOGRAPHY OF THE ODYSSEY
Christopher Nolan's new film, The Odyssey, is based on Homer's great work of fiction. For over 2,500 years, scholars have tried to match Odysseus' journey to real Mediterranean islands and coastlines.
Here's where they think Odysseus went:
1/n
Tim Minto retweeted
Ice hockey world championship: Norway wins historic bronze medal after beating Canada 3-2 in overtime 🇳🇴🏒
#hockeyworlds
Tim Minto retweeted
Not even gonna comment on the irony of citing as a parallel an event that was operationally a tactical success, but was ultimately a strategic failure — and which resulted in the downfall of an empire.
Tim Minto retweeted
"You can just do things" is basically the same heuristic as "Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face" except for people who haven't been punched in the face yet.
Tim Minto retweeted
If you asked me to choose a single acting performance that explains why the world is the way that it is I would choose this.
RIP Robert Duvall, one of the most complex and ingenious actors of the New Hollywood.
Tim Minto retweeted
Self-Portrait (rotated), potential sketch for The Creation of Adam, by Michelangelo, late 15th//early 16th c
Tim Minto retweeted
LIVE: from the World Economic Forum • EN DIRECT : au Forum économique mondial nitter.gq/i/broadcasts/1BRJjgnLV…
Tim Minto retweeted
Why would anyone continue to use humans when AI is vastly more productive?
We don’t need to speculate about what happens when massive efficiency differences exist between producers. We have that today. The inefficient producers still remain.
The most efficient white bread establishment (thinkk plant level productivity) produces 2x, 3x, even 6x as many loads of white bread as the least efficient with the same inputs. This is well documented across every country and industry studied.
I’ll just pull up the 4 digit NAICS since that’s what’s publicly available. census.gov/data/experimental…
Sort establishments by productivity. I’ll mostly use total factor productivity, TFP, but the same holds for labor productivity but is even more extreme.
What’s the gap between the 75th and 25th percentile establishment?
For the median industry (orange line), it’s about 1.7x. These numbers are even more dramatic when you look at labor productivity, where the 75-25 gap is more like 3x. Workers at the 75th percentile establishment produce 3x as much as workers at the 75th.
That's just the median industry. If we think the tail industries matter, we should think of the "dispersion of the dispersion." The blue region captures that For the 75th percentile industry (top of the blue region), the multiple is 1.9. That’s only for 75-25 industries of the 75-25 gap, not really the tails.
Do the same for 90-10. What’s the gap between the 90th percentile and 10th percentile establishment?
The median is now 3x, with the 90th percentile industry being 6x. 10% of manufacturing industries have a 6x gap in productivity.
In other words, 10% of establishments in 10% of industries are remaining open despite costs that are 6x as high.
This is what I mean when I say we don't need to speculate about how people use inefficient firms still. It happens today.
And that’s in the US, where competition is as fierce as anywhere in the world. It still doesn’t weed out the low productivity firms. worksinprogress.co/issue/how… We will return to why in a sec.
“That’s all old white bread stuff. Not the technology of the future.”
Okay. Let’s look at semiconductors (NAICS 3344). The closest thing the modern world has to robots building robots.
The 90-10 gap is 30-40x!
That’s true in measures of labor productivity and TFP, so it’s not about big capital firms. It's not about TSMC having the latest ASML machine.
If we can't eliminate productivity dispersion in semiconductor manufacturing (where advanced machines produce advanced machines in highly controlled environments) why would we expect AI to make all human labor obsolete?
Why don't the most productive firms drive out everyone else? Consumer preferences for heterogeneity matter. People pay extra for local establishments. Returns to scale matter, not every town can support a Walmart Supercenter.
Geography matters. Unless everyone is going to live in one giant city, there will always be millions of little establishments and most of them will be unproductive because they can be. (I don't see how this problem doesn't blow up when you start talking across galaxies, as @dwarkesh_sp wants us to.)
The same logic applies to AI. Yes, AI may be vastly more productive at specific tasks. But productivity differences don't automatically eliminate the less productive option.
Social science is built on the assumption there are some regulat patterns and ideas that allow you to understand across time and place.
Sure, it's always possible the future will be completely different. If that's true, I have no idea what to do to predict it. No one else does either.
Tim Minto retweeted
What happens when the U.S. restricts H-1B visas?
Firms don’t stop hiring talent, they just move jobs abroad.
For every visa rejection, multinationals add ~0.4–0.9 foreign employees, especially in R&D hubs like India, China, and Canada.
Tim Minto retweeted
Big news at the Stanley Park heron colony - the first hatchlings have arrived!📣
Newborn herons are known for their fuzzy grey mohawks and wobbly necks. Check out the chicks on our heron cam: bit.ly/4iulGQd
📷 Frank Lin
Tim Minto retweeted
The other day, this Yacht Rock cover of Teenage Dirtbag came across my Spotify algorithm. I kind of love it. Shocked it’s not more popular. I wish more songs got the Michael McDonald treatment.
Tim Minto retweeted
I asked the AI for the least inspiring inspirational poster and I weirdly like it
Tim Minto retweeted
Feels like every week I'm going to have another reason to repost this.


































