mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Yes, this is an excellent summary of what happened with ACA/Obamacare. Doctors and patients lost, but patients lost the most, because they lost choices. The next step? The next step is probably to hide the insurance companies and hospital systems behind the cloak of government with M4A (Medicare for All). People seem to think that those insurance companies they hate would go away with M4A. No, we just wouldn’t see their names very often, because they would likely be government contractors. And, there will be still fewer choices for patients along with the illusion that the costs are borne primarily by the wealthy.
Governor, @RonDeSantis you're half right. Obamacare didn't protect the insurance conglomerates. Most of them lost money and left. What it protected was the business model: a narrow network and a doctor rate so low that doctors walk.
I'm a surgeon. Here's what that looks like from my side of the desk.
Before 2010 I could buy an individual plan online for $200 a month and pick from six or seven insurers. I could go anywhere in the country. And my deductible was less than $1,500.
Yes, that was a healthy person's price, and yes, the pre-existing condition problem was real. But here's what replaced it.
The average Obamacare enrollee today can see 40% of the doctors in their area. One in four practicing physicians is in no exchange network at all. In Chicago it's 60%. Exchange patients are twice as likely as people with employer coverage to skip care because they can't find a doctor who takes their plan.
That's not insurance. That's a card.
And insurer profits did explode, just not where you'd think. UnitedHealth went from $5 billion a year to over $22 billion. The money didn't come from the exchanges. It came from the government paying private insurers to run Medicare and Medicaid, with every denied claim as margin. Obamacare didn't protect the conglomerates from competition. It made them the government's contractor.
And the competition? In 2018, half the counties in America had exactly one insurer on the exchange. It recovered, and now it's sliding again: single-insurer counties nearly doubled this year alone.
Meanwhile the law handed hospital systems every reason to buy up independent practices. They did. Private practice went from 80% of doctors to 18%. Facility fees followed. Hospital prices are up 281% since 2000. The doctor line went backwards.
So no, the insurers didn't win with exchanges. The hospital systems won. The administrators won. The patient got a plan their doctor doesn't take, a premium that went up 9% this year, and a deductible that doubled.
And now the answer from the other side is to take the rate that drove the doctors out and make it the only rate in America.
Obamacare proved that coverage is not access. Medicare for All would prove it nationwide. @KFF #obamacare #medicareforall
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Rep Khana @RoKhanna , I am a Spine Surgeon & read the Yale study. All 40 pages. Here's what the "$1 trillion in savings" actually is.
$378 billion comes from cutting drug prices 51%. You could pass that tomorrow without touching anyone's insurance. It has nothing to do with Medicare for All.
$296 billion comes from paying every hospital and doctor in America Medicare rates. That's not a saving. That's a pay cut, to the one line that's already down 33% since 2001. The model counts it as efficiency.
$286 billion is an assumed 8% cut in "fraud." Medicare's own improper payments last year: $57 billion. The government's program doesn't achieve what the model assumes a bigger version of it will.
That's $960 billion of the trillion. The rest is admin savings, which are real, and ER visits, which are modeled.
Now what the study leaves out, in the authors' own words: "provider responses to Medicare rates are not modeled." No doctors leaving. No wait times. No supply constraint. A "static, single-year accounting." They say so on the page.
And the 114,000 lives? 51,000 of them, 45% of the headline, come from reversing last year's subsidy and Medicaid cuts. Not from your bill.
Restore the subsidies and you'd get those without a single-payer system. Of what's left, half is based on a mortality number the authors say they couldn't find and had to interpolate.
It's a preprint. Not peer-reviewed. It says so at the top.
As a surgeon, I don't doubt the Yale team's intent. But a model that cuts the doctor's pay, assumes the doctor stays, assumes the patient shows up, and assumes the fraud disappears isn't evidence. It's a spreadsheet with the hard parts turned off.
Medicare already pays physicians 33% less than it did in 2001. Private practice fell from 680% of doctors to 18% on that rate. Your plan makes it the only rate. The trillion dollars is real. It's coming out of the people who treat you.
@Alison_Galvani #medicareforall
A new Yale analysis found Medicare for All would cover every American AND save more than $1 trillion a year, cutting national health care spending by 20%.
It would also mean better pay for doctors, nurses, and healthcare providers. The savings from cutting private insurance and Big Pharma profits as well as administrative waste would pay for increased Medicare reimbursement rates and $52 billion in unpaid hospital care.
Medicare for All saves money and lives.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
“Listen guys, when we say we want Medicare for all, it’s not actually going to be Medicare, it’s going to be something better and magical, just trust us, it’ll just be called Medicare but won’t have all the bad parts of Medicare, but just because every major healthcare reform before this made things worse we won’t do it again trust us this time we will get it right….”
Replying to @DrDiGiorgio
Interestingly, both patients and doctors are generally happier in those nations with universal coverage. No system is perfect and there are problems with all of them, but not to the degree we face in the US.
The M4A movement is for an improved and expanded Medicare, not our current model, though the “bones” are in place to make it easiest to enact over a 4 to 5 year span.
It removes subsidies and copayments while covering vision, hearing, dental and long-term care without the middle entities blocking medically necessary care. It covers everyone, no questions nor onerous means testing. All patients cared for represent income allowing care to move back into medical deserts. It’s an economic win for taxpayers who are currently being hosed.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Thank you. I'd do that debate tomorrow, anywhere, on the record, facts only.
I believe every American deserves healthcare as good as what a Fortune 500 CEO gets:
a doctor who knows your name, an
appointment this week, and a bill
you can read.
That isn't a partisan idea. It's a design problem, and we can solve it.
@RoKhanna, @SenSanders @AbdulElSayed the invitation is open.
Replying to @DrHMelamed @RoKhanna
I want to see Dr. Melamed on prime time television and the web discussing this study with Khanna, Sanders, & Al-Sayed. A doctor/scholar and three stooges.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Dear doctors,
They’ll do it to you until you won’t do it for them. Stop the ankle grabbing and sniveling. You hold the key. They peddle nothing without your consent and service. Honor the oath, serve the sick, tell the controllers your sacred, hard-earned knowledge, skills, experience, wisdom, and souls are not theirs to barter and sell. They are priceless. True charity is not compelled, but freely given.
Sincerely,
The dying perverse American medical system
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Senator Sanders @SenSanders, I am a Spine Surgeon & read the Yale study. All 40 pages. Here's what the "$1 trillion in savings" actually is.
$378 billion comes from cutting drug prices 51%. You could pass that tomorrow without touching anyone's insurance. It has nothing to do with Medicare for All.
$296 billion comes from paying every hospital and doctor in America Medicare rates. That's not a saving. That's a pay cut, to the one line that's already down 33% since 2001. The model counts it as efficiency.
$286 billion is an assumed 8% cut in "fraud." Medicare's own improper payments last year: $57 billion. The government's program doesn't achieve what the model assumes a bigger version of it will.
That's $960 billion of the trillion. The rest is admin savings, which are real, and ER visits, which are modeled.
Now what the study leaves out, in the authors' own words: "provider responses to Medicare rates are not modeled." No doctors leaving. No wait times. No supply constraint. A "static, single-year accounting." They say so on the page.
And the 114,000 lives? 51,000 of them, 45% of the headline, come from reversing last year's subsidy and Medicaid cuts. Not from your bill.
Restore the subsidies and you'd get those without a single-payer system. Of what's left, half is based on a mortality number the authors say they couldn't find and had to interpolate.
It's a preprint. Not peer-reviewed. It says so at the top.
As a surgeon, I don't doubt the Yale team's intent. But a model that cuts the doctor's pay, assumes the doctor stays, assumes the patient shows up, and assumes the fraud disappears isn't evidence. It's a spreadsheet with the hard parts turned off.
Medicare already pays physicians 33% less than it did in 2001. Private practice fell from 680% of doctors to 18% on that rate. Your plan makes it the only rate. The trillion dollars is real. It's coming out of the people who treat you.
@Alison_Galvani #medicareforall
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Amazing what can be accomplished with price transparency and getting rid of unnecessary middlemen extracting billions from the healthcare system. Well done @costplusdrugs
Another day another price drop from CostPlusDrugs.com.
Name one pharmacy that has EVER pushed prices down like we have !
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
You want to save healthcare in the US? Give private practitioners a level playing field and allow a free market for healthcare.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
A free society absolutely requires independent physicians
Bring back private practice to make American healthcare more accessible for all
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Perhaps the stupidest thing I have seen on social media in weeks. And that says a lot.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Medicine is the only profession where we throw each other under the bus while horde of bureaucrats with internet degrees snatches control of us all .
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Governor, @RonDeSantis you're half right. Obamacare didn't protect the insurance conglomerates. Most of them lost money and left. What it protected was the business model: a narrow network and a doctor rate so low that doctors walk.
I'm a surgeon. Here's what that looks like from my side of the desk.
Before 2010 I could buy an individual plan online for $200 a month and pick from six or seven insurers. I could go anywhere in the country. And my deductible was less than $1,500.
Yes, that was a healthy person's price, and yes, the pre-existing condition problem was real. But here's what replaced it.
The average Obamacare enrollee today can see 40% of the doctors in their area. One in four practicing physicians is in no exchange network at all. In Chicago it's 60%. Exchange patients are twice as likely as people with employer coverage to skip care because they can't find a doctor who takes their plan.
That's not insurance. That's a card.
And insurer profits did explode, just not where you'd think. UnitedHealth went from $5 billion a year to over $22 billion. The money didn't come from the exchanges. It came from the government paying private insurers to run Medicare and Medicaid, with every denied claim as margin. Obamacare didn't protect the conglomerates from competition. It made them the government's contractor.
And the competition? In 2018, half the counties in America had exactly one insurer on the exchange. It recovered, and now it's sliding again: single-insurer counties nearly doubled this year alone.
Meanwhile the law handed hospital systems every reason to buy up independent practices. They did. Private practice went from 80% of doctors to 18%. Facility fees followed. Hospital prices are up 281% since 2000. The doctor line went backwards.
So no, the insurers didn't win with exchanges. The hospital systems won. The administrators won. The patient got a plan their doctor doesn't take, a premium that went up 9% this year, and a deductible that doubled.
And now the answer from the other side is to take the rate that drove the doctors out and make it the only rate in America.
Obamacare proved that coverage is not access. Medicare for All would prove it nationwide. @KFF #obamacare #medicareforall
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Americans want health insurance that costs less and covers more.
Then americans vote for politicians who make it nearly impossible to build new hospitals and medical facilities.
Then Americans vote to hand mandatory drug discounts (over $250 billion worth in 2025) to non-profit hospitals instead of patients.
Then Americans voted to cap how many doctors we train, then complain they can't get an appointment.
Then Americans vote to ban catastrophic insurance and then complain insurance is too expensive.
Good and appropriate healthcare is available. Americans voted to remove it.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
This. Going after physician reimbursements is the definition of penny wise, pound stupid. Physicians are 8-9% of expenditures. So in la la land where there are no higher order effects the best case scenario for cutting reimbursements _by half_ is a 5% savings. In the real world this will massively reduce the supply of doctors *immediately*, it will reduce the quality of people in the pipeline, and the slack will be taken up by less intelligent, less qualified practitioners who *cost the system more.* (look at the data on midlevels in primary care. They spend a lot more on rads and other diagnostics because they don’t know how to dx by history and exam.)
“5% savings only cost us a 30% net increase”
Replying to @PatrickHeizer
We currently select highest performing college students, then convince them to grin and bear it for 4+3-7 years of an inhumane training pipeline... by selling them on job security / upper middle class lifestyle
you want infinity docs to be avg intelligence martyrs to save 5%?
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
The vast majority of physicians now work for hospitals or other corporate entities like insurance companies. Private practice has become a smaller and smaller part of our medical system — to the detriment of patients and physicians.
Replying to @RonDeSantis
All the small practitioners went broke too.
So sad for us physicians and for our patients.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
We do not have a system of nationalized healthcare in America. We have a market that serves some more than others, and some not at all.
We have not even agreed as a nation on a baseline level of healthcare that all citizens deserve.
But we can all recognize that too much power has been accumulated and abused by institutions that exploit our human desire for health to maximize profits.
It’s time to rebalance the forces to protect patients and the people who serve them.
I’d love to hear from healthcare workers. What do you need most to keep the light of healthcare burning?
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Amazon has over 12k workers on SNAP benefits and over 11k workers on Medicaid. Yet Amazon receives billions in tax subsidies every year. If Amazon is getting all these tax dollars shouldn’t they be required to at least pay their workers a living wage?
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
You don’t hate hospitals enough.
Hospital prices have more than quadrupled since 2000—rising far faster than other health care costs and everyday expenses like housing and food.
More in our new analysis: on.kff.org/4zYyrvQ

ALT The KFF graph is showing cumulative percent change in the Consumer Price Index for urban consumers from January 2000 to October 2026. Hospital services increased by 314%, overall medical care by 133%, housing by 118%, food/beverage by 109%, prescription drugs by 94%, and overall inflation by 100%.
mezcal.eth - The Elixir of the Gods retweeted
Amazon is a multi-trillion dollar company. If Jeff Bezos adds $5 to your order, it’s not because of City Council's efforts to protect workers' rights and keep our streets safe. It's greed.
Pass the Delivery Protection Act.































