Hash2 T retweeted
With all the harm done to millions in the name of religion one may think we are still in the Middle Age.
Hash2 T retweeted
I have just completed a three-day swim through the Strait of Hormuz. I went there to bring attention to the devastating environmental cost of war.
Associated Press has published the first account of the swim. Please read it, and help share it.
apnews.com/article/strait-of…
Photos: Kelvin Trautman / Lewis Pugh Foundation
#HormuzSwim
Hash2 T retweeted
۱۴ نفتکش ایرانی و آزمونی که میتواند معادلات جنگ را تغییر دهد …
بر اساس گزارشها و تصاویر ماهوارهای منتشرشده، ظاهراً ایران در حال بارگیری ۱۴ نفتکش است تا با به حرکت درآوردن این ناوگان، محاصره دریایی آمریکا را بشکند و احتمالاً محمولههای نفتی را به مقصد چین منتقل کند.
اگر این گزارشها صحت داشته باشد، ما با یک اتفاق معمولی در تجارت نفت مواجه نیستیم. این تصمیم میتواند یکی از مهمترین و حساسترین رویاروییهای ایران و آمریکا در این مرحله از جنگ باشد
در یک طرف، تهدیدهای منتسب به آمریکا مطرح است که اجازه خروج نفتکشهای حامل نفت ایران از تنگه هرمز را نخواهد داد و در طرف دیگر، گزارشهایی از هشدار سپاه منتشر شده که هرگونه حمله به این ناوگان را با پاسخ نظامی علیه زیرساختهای کشورهای منطقه مواجه خواهد کرد. از امارات و کویت گرفته تا بحرین و عمان.
در این میان، گمانهزنیهایی هم درباره تفاهم احتمالی واشنگتن، پکن و مسکو مطرح شده است. اینکه شاید در گفتوگوهای سهجانبه در چین، توافقی نانوشته شکل گرفته یا دستکم پکن توانسته تضمینهایی بگیرد که آمریکا مانع حرکت نفتکشها نشود.
من برای چنین فرضیهای بدون شواهد معتبر ارزشی بیش از یک گمانهزنی قائل نیستم. ممکن است پشت پرده توافقی وجود داشته باشد و ممکن است تمام این محاسبات اشتباه باشد
اما مسئله اصلی جای دیگری است.
ایران، اگر واقعاً تصمیم به اعزام این ناوگان گرفته باشد، آمریکا را در برابر یک انتخاب دشوار قرار میدهد.
اگر نفتکشها حرکت کنند و بدون درگیری از محدوده محاصره عبور کنند، تهران موفق شده است در عمل یکی از مهمترین محدودیتهای تحمیلشده از سوی آمریکا را به چالش بکشد. چنین اتفاقی برای اعتبار تهدیدهای واشنگتن هزینه سنگینی خواهد داشت و میتواند موازنه روانی و سیاسی این رویارویی را به سود ایران تغییر دهد.
اما اگر آمریکا به نفتکشها حمله کند، احتمالاً ماجرا دیگر به چند کشتی و محموله نفت محدود نخواهد ماند. پاسخ احتمالی ایران و گسترش درگیری به زیرساختهای کشورهای منطقه میتواند جنگ را وارد مرحلهای بهمراتب خطرناکتر کند.
من با آگاهی از همین خطرات، از تصمیم ایران برای شکستن محاصره دریایی حمایت میکنم. هیچ کشوری نباید بپذیرد که یک قدرت خارجی بتواند برای همیشه مسیر تجارت و صادرات نفتش را با تهدید نظامی مسدود کند. شکستن چنین محاصرهای، اگر با محاسبه درست و آمادگی کافی انجام شود، دفاع از حق حاکمیت و منافع ملی ایران است.
اما میخواهم از تمام این محاسبات سیاسی و نظامی فاصله بگیرم و درباره کسانی حرف بزنم که بار واقعی این تصمیم بر دوش آنهاست
ملوانان ایرانی، کارکنان نفتکشها، فرماندهان و نیروهای نظامی که قرار است در این مأموریت حضور داشته باشند.
برای من این آدمها فقط خدمه چند کشتی یا نیروهای حاضر در یک عملیات نیستند. آنها مردانی هستند که ممکن است با آگاهی از احتمال حمله، کشتیهایشان را به دل یکی از خطرناکترین رویاروییهای نظامی منطقه ببرند.
کسانی که شاید همین امروز با خانوادههایشان صحبت کردهاند، شاید فرزندی منتظر بازگشتشان باشد و شاید خودشان بهتر از هر کسی بدانند که این سفر میتواند آخرین مأموریت زندگیشان باشد
ممکن است امروز نامشان را ندانیم، تصویرشان را ندیده باشیم و حتی ندانیم چند نفرند، اما فردا نام همین مردان را در فهرست شهدای ایران بخوانیم.
فکر کردن به همین احتمال برای من کافی است تا احترامم به آنها چند برابر شود.
من در تمام این سالها بارها از تصمیمات سیاسی و نظامی کشور انتقاد کردهام و هر جا لازم بدانم باز هم انتقاد خواهم کرد. اما وقتی پای دفاع از ایران، حاکمیت ملی و ایستادگی در برابر محاصرهای تحمیلی در میان باشد، حمایت من از نیروهای مسلح کشورم روشن است
برای من شجاعت این مردان چیزی فراتر از اجرای یک دستور نظامی است. آنها قرار است در خط مقدم تصمیمی بایستند که دربارهاش در اتاقهای فرماندهی و محافل سیاسی بحث میشود، اما اگر گلولهای شلیک شود، این جان آنهاست که پیش از هر چیز در معرض خطر قرار میگیرد.
من از شکستن محاصره دریایی ایران حمایت میکنم، از نیروهای نظامی کشورم حمایت میکنم و در برابر مردانی که برای انجام این مأموریت خطر مرگ را به جان میخرند، با تمام وجود کلاه از سر برمیدارم.
امیدوارم این کاروان مأموریتش را با موفقیت انجام دهد، محاصره شکسته شود و همه این مردان سرافراز و سلامت به خانه برگردند.
و اگر روزی قرار باشد از این مأموریت در تاریخ ایران یاد شود، امیدوارم پیش از نام سیاستمداران و فرماندهان، نام همان ملوانان و نیروهایی ثبت شود که با جان خود پای این تصمیم ایستادند.
درود بر مردانی که برای سربلندی ایران، خطر را به جان میخرند.
Hash2 T retweeted
In his memoirs, Biden said Israel went too far in Gaza, and he accused Netanyahu of having “Trump-like tendencies.”
But a transcript of his final call with Netanyahu before leaving office tells a completely different story.
The transcript reveals that Biden told Netanyahu, “You’re a good man” and “I admire you.”
Even worse, he said he admires Netanyahu - a wanted war criminal - and even told him: "It took a lot of courage to do what you did.”
Netanyahu did a genocide.
jpost.com/american-politics/…
Hash2 T retweeted
BREAKING: NEW YORK TIME GETS COMMUNITY NOTED!
The New York Times has been community noted following their utterly abysmal response to their disgusting article published recently that clearly sought to manufacture consent for strikes on Iran’s water infrastructure and dams.
In responding to the OVERWHELMING criticism that article received, The New York Times PR team released a statement that doubled down on the article and actively BLAMED readers, calling them “dangerous” for identifying that this article was establishing the pretext for future American military strikes.
Immediately following the release of this article, almost every expert that was quoted in the piece immediately condemned its implied conclusion, and it is abundantly clear that the journalists, Sanam Mahoozi and Erika Solomon, deliberately misled these individuals, seeking to launder their professional reputations to lend credibility to the article whose own author when initially promoting the piece to X, acknowledged that there was “no conclusion evidence”.
In a viral post yesterday, I called for the immediate retraction of this article from The New York Times, and for a public apology to be made to their readers, as well as a condemnation of the implication that water infrastructure should fall under dual-use infrastructure in a future U.S. bombing campaign.
I also followed up with an email to Nicole Taylor herself this morning.
Taking a page from The New York Times’ own playbook, I too will double down:
@nytimes and @NYTimesPR:
Immediately move to retract this piece, issue an apology to your readers, and condemn the implication that water infrastructure should fall under dual-use categorization.
Hash2 T retweeted
URGENT: I call for @nytimes and @NYTimesPR to immediately retract their article entitled, "War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason" published on November 16th by Erika Solomon and Sanam Mahoozi and issue an immediate statement as to the illegality of targeting Iranian water infrastructure.
In this piece, Solomon and Mahoozi are clearly attempting to manufacture consent for the categorization of Iranian dams and water infrastructure under "dual use infrastructure". This would allow for the United States to have the pretext under international law to target these sites despite the lead reporter on the piece, Sanam Mahoozi, posting the article to X yesterday stating:
"Could some water projects have served to support Iran’s military buildup? No conclusive evidence—but questions worth asking."
According to the X post from Mahoozi, this investigation from The New York Times took "months", but as per her own statement, resulted in zero conclusive evidence.
In addition to this, almost every expert that was quoted by Mahoozi and Solomon on the piece have subsequently issued public statements rebuking the framing and conclusion of the article. This is clearly as a result of Mahoozi and Solomon not being forthcoming with these experts as to what the narrative being pushed by the article would be.
Nima Shokri, Danny Citrinowicz, Nik Kowsar, and Amir Aghakouchak, four separate experts quoted in the article have all issued public statements criticizing the framing and conclusion of the piece.
When an article implicitly seeks to manufacture consent for war crimes, finds no conclusive evidence, and is immediately condemned by the very experts quoted on the piece, it should be clear that it is blatantly dishonest and immoral to publish such an article.
@nytimes and @NYTimesPR should immediately remove to retract the article and condemn the implied conclusion that water infrastructure in Iran falls under dual-use infrastructure.
Honesty and truth seeking is the most valuable journalism trait. Evidence based truth seeking is ethical. Impartiality has become a tool for the corrupt to silence the truth.Nobody can ever be impartial. We are naturally opinionated. But an ethical person can always say the truth
Watch former BBC Hardtalk frontman Stephen Sackur blow the whistle on the anti-Palestinian racism endemic at the BBC:
22
Hash2 T retweeted
Who are the seven experts whose research and analysis you claim to have “accurately cited”?
Where can we find that research and analysis? What exactly did they conclude?
I’m one of the people quoted in the article, but my comments had nothing to do with dams or missiles!
Iranian officials and others have rejected a Times report, which, citing analysts, described a potential link between water infrastructure and military projects. Our response:

ALT “Our report on Iranian dams accurately cited research and analysis by seven international experts on Iran’s environment and military presence. Our journalists provided readers with a deeper understanding of Iranian infrastructure investment and the effects of U.S. and Israeli attacks on civilians. Framing the independent reporting as a pretext for violence is dangerous.” —Nicole Taylor, a spokesperson for The New York Times
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
NYT's own cited experts have pushed back on its dual-use claims for civilian water infrastructure, calling them speculative and dangerous. Kaveh Madani: forbes.com/sites/kavehmad… x.com/KavehMadani/st… Nima Shokri: x.com/NimaShokri_GHI…
I disagree with @yarbatman, Unless he is trying to give NYT an escape route to apology. Acceptable, only if they act quickly.
Mainstream trusted media leave their “bloopers” for exceptional occasions and it almost always facilitates the catastrophe “as an unfortunate error”
One more thing on the NYT story on Iranian dams that needs to be said.
I’ve spoken to @ErikaSolomon and @SanamMahoozi on numerous occasions. They’re great reporters and committed to their craft.
Sometimes the process of reporting and editing leads to a story that just doesn’t hold water, to use an apt metaphor.
Journalists should be judged on their bodies of work, not on singular stories.
I’m sure Erika and Sanam will continue to tell important stories about Iran.
46
Hash2 T retweeted
My response in Forbes to the recent New York Times article linking Iran’s dams to missiles, in which I was also quoted, but my comments were unrelated to the alleged connection:
forbes.com/sites/kavehmadani…
Journalism carries a responsibility to distinguish evidence from speculation, especially during armed conflicts when misleading narratives can endanger civilian lives and infrastructure.
Hash2 T retweeted
In the past 72 hours, pro-Israel media have "reported" that Iran is supposedly plotting to use chemical weapons in DC while building missile bases under dams. RUBBISH.
Spare us the Iraq War-style propaganda, especially with Israeli fingerprints all over it. Nobody is buying it.
Hash2 T retweeted
Speculation is not evidence. Spatial proximity is not causality.
Even those who attacked Iran have not made such claims linking dams to missiles!
This reductionist, sensational narrative is irresponsible journalism with potentially dangerous consequences for civilian water infrastructure.
The @nytimes should know better.
Hash2 T retweeted
Today’s New York Times report on how the Islamic Republic’s water projects are tied to its missile program has people reading it in very different ways. I want to be clear about where I stand: I oppose any attack on civilian infrastructure, whoever carries it out and whatever reason is given. No report, investigation, or revelation changes that.
nikkowsar.substack.com/p/rem…
Replying to @HosseinGhatib
دست در دست هم دهیم به مهر
میهن خویش را کنیم آباد
ما فقط همدیگر را داریم
when the Israel ramped up the most blatant genocide in modern times post WWII, the excuse was Hamas is hiding itself within civilian infrastructure. The unconditional condemnation outrage should have started then to avoid the eventuality of making another false narrative. Act now
The @nytimes and its journalists are busy manufacturing justifications for further attacks on Iranian civilians and civilian infrastructure.
Iran has a long history of engineering and building major water infrastructure, often under sanctions and enormous economic constraints. Its dams, tunnels, and water-transfer systems are part of that history, however legitimate the criticisms of their environmental consequences.
Yet the New York Times takes decades of Iranian engineering and infrastructure development and recasts them as a possible extension of the country's military programme.
On what evidence? A supposed geographical overlap between dams and sites bombed by the US and Israel, speculation about military requirements, and the assessments of a former Israeli military intelligence analyst. No demonstrated causal relationship, no evidence that these projects were built for military purposes, and no convincing explanation of why military considerations should take precedence over civilian ones.
The authors themselves admit they have no conclusive evidence. Yet the article proceeds to turn speculation into suspicion and suspicion into a narrative of military infrastructure.
This is how manufacturing consent works. Civilian infrastructure is progressively reframed as a military asset, making its destruction appear more defensible. Publishing such insinuations while Iran is under attack is journalism serving the logic of imperial war. @SanamMahoozi @ErikaSolomon
24
Hash2 T retweeted
I fully agree. Dams and water infrastructure are essential to civilian life and must never become targets of military attacks. Regardless of their location or potential strategic significance, their primary roles in water supply, food security, energy, and environmental sustainability must not be overlooked. Protecting these critical resources should be a priority, regardless of politics or conflict.
Hash2 T retweeted
I want to clarify my position regarding the recent New York Times article on dam construction in Iran: the proximity of dams to military targets does not establish why those dams were built, nor does it justify attacks on them.
Replying to @KavehMadani
نام شما با (یا بی)اجازه بعنوان یک قربانی نظام سیاسی و یک متخصص تراز اول بعنوان سند اعتبار یک #مزخرف مورد سوء استفاده قرار گرفته
Do not beat around the bush
Write in English and refer to NYT article addressing your statements as baseless or false. So international community know































