Hans Eric Melin retweeted
.@hanseric on 🔥:
== Wake Up @EU_Commission ==
Hans:✍️✍️
"This while China's sales of BEV/PHEVs this year's first two months increased by 52% taking the BEV/PHEV share to 45.5% of the entire car market."
#alwaysbecharging
.@hanseric tells it better than most:
"Today's announcement from the @EU_Commission 🇪🇺 means that European recyclers and midstream material producers will face a complicated future🔋♻️🏭.
Carmakers get two extra years to comply with 2025 CO2 targets. The sum of the next years remains the same (they can do 1+2+3 or 1+1+4 instead of 2+2+2) but such a trajectory was by many expected anyway as a way to comply with the 2030 target (like 2+3+4).
The EU will explore direct support for EU battery producers as "we cannot let EVs become more expensive, but we also cannot afford to create new dependencies".
Given that current battery factories in Europe, despite several suspensions, are running far below capacity this cannot mean anything else than direct subsidies for each kWh produced similar to the #AMPTC in the US, can it?
That support has certainly been helpful, in fact without it three of the largest battery makers in the US would have made big losses last year.
The question is how large such a subsidy needs to be if it should contribute to cheaper vehicles, higher profitability for cell makers – and higher profitability in local battery material production.
As late as last week, the Commission singled out black mass as a material the EU wants to take extra measures to limit its movement to countries overseas.
All in the name of the circular economy. But currently there is basically no way for that material to re-enter the battery value chain in Europe. So without further investments, a decision like that will make EVs less circular than what they are today.
In theory this sounds like a great opportunity for companies with financial strength and a strong faith to invest in pCAM production and material recovery in EU. But then we come to what was maybe most striking in today's announcement – the lack of growth incentives 🚀.
There was nothing about replacing sticks with carrots. In fact the sticks are only replaced by another stick when carmakers most likely will face requirements on local content.
So what will the automotive industry get?
Two more years of higher margins without the risk for fines while the challenge to turn profits from EVs in the future only increased.
This while China's sales of BEV/PHEVs this year's first two months increased by 52% taking the BEV/PHEV share to 45.5% of the entire car market.
I think there is a considerable risk that while the Chinese market continues to gain experience, increase productivity and continue to add economies of scale the Korean/European/US value chains will continue to struggle primarily from sluggish demand but also from challenging changes in technology with a gradual change to LFP cathode.
In such an environment, and with last year's events fresh in mind, I think it now will take more than 3D renderings of 500 meter long factories to attract investors.
Not least as they this time may ask if it at all is possible to make money in this market."
#alwaysbecharging
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
.@hanseric tells it better than most:
"Today's announcement from the @EU_Commission 🇪🇺 means that European recyclers and midstream material producers will face a complicated future🔋♻️🏭.
Carmakers get two extra years to comply with 2025 CO2 targets. The sum of the next years remains the same (they can do 1+2+3 or 1+1+4 instead of 2+2+2) but such a trajectory was by many expected anyway as a way to comply with the 2030 target (like 2+3+4).
The EU will explore direct support for EU battery producers as "we cannot let EVs become more expensive, but we also cannot afford to create new dependencies".
Given that current battery factories in Europe, despite several suspensions, are running far below capacity this cannot mean anything else than direct subsidies for each kWh produced similar to the #AMPTC in the US, can it?
That support has certainly been helpful, in fact without it three of the largest battery makers in the US would have made big losses last year.
The question is how large such a subsidy needs to be if it should contribute to cheaper vehicles, higher profitability for cell makers – and higher profitability in local battery material production.
As late as last week, the Commission singled out black mass as a material the EU wants to take extra measures to limit its movement to countries overseas.
All in the name of the circular economy. But currently there is basically no way for that material to re-enter the battery value chain in Europe. So without further investments, a decision like that will make EVs less circular than what they are today.
In theory this sounds like a great opportunity for companies with financial strength and a strong faith to invest in pCAM production and material recovery in EU. But then we come to what was maybe most striking in today's announcement – the lack of growth incentives 🚀.
There was nothing about replacing sticks with carrots. In fact the sticks are only replaced by another stick when carmakers most likely will face requirements on local content.
So what will the automotive industry get?
Two more years of higher margins without the risk for fines while the challenge to turn profits from EVs in the future only increased.
This while China's sales of BEV/PHEVs this year's first two months increased by 52% taking the BEV/PHEV share to 45.5% of the entire car market.
I think there is a considerable risk that while the Chinese market continues to gain experience, increase productivity and continue to add economies of scale the Korean/European/US value chains will continue to struggle primarily from sluggish demand but also from challenging changes in technology with a gradual change to LFP cathode.
In such an environment, and with last year's events fresh in mind, I think it now will take more than 3D renderings of 500 meter long factories to attract investors.
Not least as they this time may ask if it at all is possible to make money in this market."
#alwaysbecharging
.@WilliamTodts: ✍️
"The car lobby got what they wanted: a change to the 2025 standards in the middle of the compliance year
The @EU_Commission will propose a change to the 2025 law to allow for averaging between 2025-27. A seperate, 2nd proposal on 2035 would come soon after"
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
The total of the three orders equivalent to 30% of global grid-scale storage in 2024 or 786k BEVs.
#battchat #energystorage
China 🇨🇳is expanding clean energy ties in Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦.
On #enerystorage side:
#CATL /Masdar 19GWh, #BYD /SEC 12.5 GWh, Sungrow/Algihaz 7.8 GWh
Saudi Arabia helps these 3 companies secure the largest ever storage order.
#BATTCHAT
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
.@hanseric: ✍️&📸
"Opel Rocks is everywhere in Amsterdam!"
❌❌❌
#amsterdamelektrisch #alwaysbecharging
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
there's great people
and there's @hanseric:
"This comes back to the big questions that we have been pushing for some years: by whom and where will EVs be made in the future?
When the European EV market so far this year has decreased by 3.1% (in volume) the Chinese market has increased by 32.5%. The PHEV/BEV penetration rate in China was 53.3% in September.
In fact, in september there were more EVs sold in China than cars in Europe."
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Love these stories by @_HannahRitchie
To dive deeper on this topic, check out the interview referenced between @MLiebreich and @hanseric here:
cleaningup.live/battery-recy…
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Critics of EVs often point out that just 5% of lithium-ion batteries are recycled.
But, surprise, there's no evidence for that claim!
sustainabilitybynumbers.com/…
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Many people like Chris believe that there’s no way to dispose let alone recycle batteries.
@MLiebreich recently spoke to @hanseric a leading battery recycling expert who explains that about 90% of batteries are recycled.
nitter.gq/mliebreich/status/1798…
unavailable
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
NOW STREAMING!
"The world is already quite circular!"
@hanseric and @MLiebreich explore the future circularity of battery critical minerals, and the surpassing notion that much industry of the last 50 years has been circular.
Episode now streaming: cleaningup.live
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Only 5% of Li-ion batteries are recycled, right? WRONG! The real figure is over 90%. In fact there is far more battery recycling capacity than end-of life batteries. What the hell is going on? Get the real story on this week's @CleaningUpPod with @hanseric cleaningup.live/battery-recy…
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
This factoid surprised even me! But I absolutely trust @hanseric on this. This promises to be an interesting episode on lithium battery recycling!
NEW EPISODE!
"It's not true!"
This week on Cleaning Up, @MLiebreich talks to @hanseric - Founder @CircularStorage - the world's preeminent expert on battery recycling. Hans busts the famous myth that only 5% of lithium-ion batteries are recycled.
Full episode out Wednesday!
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Funny. I was part of the PR team that launched the original BYD electric bus in London about a decade ago. And here is a quote from @BorisJohnson in 2015:
bydeurope.com/article/205
Sadiq Khan is using a Chinese firm to make electric buses. This is what Labour’s energy transition looks like - they’ll hike your taxes and send the money to China.
We are supporting homegrown innovation and giving time for British supply chains to grow.
thetimes.co.uk/article/46607…
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Active exports of ex 2018 NL🇳🇱 lease JAGs to Ukraine? ✅
(hard to even sell them for 20K on the Dutch 2nd hand market, partly because of 1F AC charging)
this does not surprise either @hanseric or @Nokius
⚡️⚡️⚡️
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
#alwaysbecharging
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
I LOVE this new post by my friend (and sometimes foe ;-) @MLiebreich on the five superheroes that might keep climate change below 2C while making us more affluent.
about.bnef.com/blog/liebreic…
My main take-aways in a short thread.
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Hans is delivering an IMPORTANT message. The majority of research, news articles quote only 5 % of used lithium ion batteries are recycled today and the rest is ending up in land waste. This is NOT TRUE! According to data in 2019, 59 % of used lithium ion batteries are recycled. Please repost and spread the message. #battchat
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
This is huge!
All design & engineering of the original @Tesla Roadster is now fully open source.
Whatever we have, you now have.
service.tesla.com/roadster
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Replying to @ned2au @DavidGlynneJon1 @GlenneDrover @nicknet100 @evcricket @TimLloydArts @RoderickBeck @BieglerTom @markcojuangco @BarnardBryan @jm493_au @roobar99 @cat240359 @JC47053522 @EdPheil @icowrich @FollowTheScien4 @k_salberta @sideen_dan @EarnestBunbury1 @joelmcourtney @LesleyG78347579 @JohnLovell60 @hughosmond @unclepete_100 @dale_wen @AustNuclear @xiaowang1984 @DavidOsmond8 @cadlam @TheOmeg55211733 @AlScottRational @Ramosen26 @AlanPeery @aliebman @EnergyJvd @Nuclearjunkie @LesJohnsonHrvat @Daniel03187025 @civilengineer @james_jobrien @FissionGoing @montaguethecat @diggerdeegs
Recommend watching the recent UK parliament inquiry on the subject of battery recycling ➡️parliamentlive.tv/Event/Inde…
And since I had to google "victorian sponge" … looks lovely doesn't it?
😉
Quite an apt analogy too, just like the "too many monks & not enough porridge" (ht: @hanseric @gavindjharper )
So: Just to be clear on my point of contention: Li-Ion battery recycling is happening & it will continue to keep happening, if only for the simple reason that countries, economic blocks don't want to be fully dependent on imported raw materials.
The rest are questions of regulation, enforcement & maturing technology chains towards more circularity potential.
The same kind of potential that you personally absolutely see possible for nuclear fuel, but not for a competing technology, so your a bit off the cuff dismissal strikes me as odd & possibly myopic (?)
Can't work bc it's potentially business case destroying for nuclear(?)
which is strange, bc it seems more or less well accepted by other nuclear advocates on this thread (eg @vass_and ) that NPP's will need some sort of buffer to be viable in future res-dominated grid environments (can't find the smr proposal that @vass_and posted about which had the buffer built in rn)
Hans Eric Melin retweeted
Great to be quoted in this piece by @markpeplow in @cenmag alongside @hanseric Melin.
cen.acs.org/environment/recy…
Drawing on work @unibirmingham, @bhamenergy, Birmingham Centre for Strategic Elements & Critical Materials #BCSECM on @FaradayInst @ReLiBProject, @Met4Tech &#TReFCo.































